BirdmanG07's Profile

I'm enjoying this a lot, but if this was main continuity Batman I'm sure I'd feel differently. I like that it's a separate universe story.

Outstanding read

Enter BANE. Not Bane, BANE. You'll get it after you read it.

WHAT. A. READ. Hilarious, appropriate, outstanding.

Something was off about the wrong in some parts on this one.

What a ride

The only thing bad about this book is it was a special and not in the main series, probably a money grab. Truly a dark, disturbing tale, possibly the darkest of the absolute Batman run.

I enjoyed it, but there's too many other Absolute books that are better and I can't get them all.

I can see why people would enjoy this, just not my cup of tea.

Stakes are high, let's see if they can do anything with this.

I'm shockingly a fan of these absolute books

Great read, really liking this series.

The landing was indeed stuck.

Great read. Love the Hawkman take.

This was quite an interesting take, excited to see where this goes.

Solid first arc. I'm a big Wonder Woman fan, but something about this may not be for me. I'm undecided if I'll get the next arc.

Gets a little bump from how gorgeous the art is. The lighting work was phenomenal. Back stories were cute.

I thought this was a really cool mini arc

Introduction for the two characters was very well done.

My problem with this issue, and this entire run, hasn't been the separation of MJ and Peter, it's the circumstances around it. The status quo prior to this was completely disregarded and we just jumped into these new events. This seems more to me like Marvel wanting to sell books out of shock value and Wells wanting to force Felicia/Peter rather than telling a good story. MJ, one of the most well known characters in Marvel, was paired up with a random guy we've never heard of. Even after this it seems more from circumstance and going through a terrible 4 years than growing together. It's disrespectful to MJ. I saw another review that said if Paul/MJ have a trauma based relationship, by that logic Peter/MJ should've been married with 12 kids from what they went though. I admittedly wanted MJ/Peter but I'm open to it not working out if it's done right. I do think this could've been a good interesting story, but again it feels more rushed and forced than anything. Plus nothing here was a surprise, we all saw this coming. The only surprise was the kids weren't birthed from MJ. I've liked past work by Wells, I was excited to have him in the book and was hoping #25 would change my opinion but it hasn't. I am hoping 26 makes it worth it but if they just kill off MJ, I don't know how they got this story approved. It was teased in this with the "if you get 3 skulls" and I feel like we're about to see that next issue.

There's a lot to like in the story, really. But how they ended the primary story was beyond frustrating. Again Marvel billing something big for sales, and it's not. More stuff that was previously setup potentially thrown down the drain - emphasis on potentially. This could be a drama turn that leads somewhere. Billing/marketing something for something it's not will always bring down scores for me, especially when it's a more expensive issue. If you like JRJR, more of the same. If you hate his work, he doesn't do all of the pages so you get a break from it. As for the side stories, as much as I hate Paul the MJ story was almost amazing. My issue is *spoiler the rest of the way* MJ does not need to be a super hero. She has stood on her own for decades because of who she is. I don't know who pushed to idea forward but IMO they don't fully understand what makes MJ great. I will admit, clever with the name. Other side stories are typical things you find in these thick issues.

HATED the prior story arc and everything they're doing with MJ. This book? This was great. The art on the Kraven pages? Stupendous. *feel that it's worth mentioning someone who hated the prior arc enjoyed this issue.

Another great one by Wells? Keep MJ away and he does good work?

Solid issue, the art was done very well and fit the vibe. Biggest downside is Paul's stupid face is in it.

Random fill in issue for a big event. It was fine for what it was. I dislike JRJRs art, but I will give credit when it's due. There were actually some nice panels in this one. The cover is mediocre though.

I have NOT enjoyed a lot of this run. This book? This book was really good. It does lose half a point because it was $10. The book prices are high enough, I don't need the extra back stories. That being said, the back stories were fine. Glad JRJR is nowhere to be seen, inside or on the cover.

I still think the start of this run was horrendous. I still think anytime he touches MJ it's garbage. But, the little things that he's planted along the way, are they actually going to pay off? Great job on the art.

Giving it a score for what it is. One of the best arcs Wells has had was only a couple issues, and it's a big part of what led to this arc. It looks like this might be another short lived scenario, but we don't know yet. Again, haven't been a fan of his run as a whole but I'll give credit where it's due.

Art is great and holds the book up a lot for me. An ending we've already had a few issues ago? A questionable choice, which seems to be a theme of this entire run.

Honestly it's just disappointing how much the ball was dropped to start Wells's run was, Paul and the unforgettable villain from that story arc set Wells up way behind the 8 ball. While this current arc wasn't bad, it did have its problems and feels easier to pick apart because of the dislike of his earlier issues. I enjoyed Wells's work prior to him getting on Amazing Spider-Man, I hope the backlash he received here hasn't disheartened him and he turns it around in the next book he does. He's got 6 issues left, I hope he finishes ok.

It was a sweet story. Maybe if he did stuff like this from the get go instead of blowing it all up at the start he wouldn't have gotten all the hate he received.

I'd give this a higher score if it wasn't an $8 comic with a whole bunch of short stories to round out the back. I did appreciate that it was the same writer and some of them tied together, but the extra money books with multiple stories rarely sit well with me. The main story turned the entire previous arc into a nothing burger. The section with aunt May later was nice, but all the Tombstone court stuff means nothing now. Other than being genuinely disappointed with how the story worked, this was some of Wells better work on ASM. It seems like he's been able to run free some in the later issues and before in the behind book, and that's when he was at his best. As a whole run goes, I think this was a failure. I like Zeb Wells as a writer, but this whole run was just not for me. I still think the creation of Jackpot shows Wells/Lowe don't understand what makes MJ special as a character. I don't care for Rek-Rap, of the Miles equivalent for that matter. And I'm not going to get started on MJ and the guy who I honestly cannot remember the name of that she's with now. There was a letter in the back where someone wrote in basically calling out Lowe on how stagnant ASM has been as a whole, and I agreed with damn near every word. Thank you Dapper Dan from MD, I hope somehow you see this. I'd say I'm looking forward to the fresh start, but I honestly don't know. If I wasn't trying to collect the entirety of the run I would've dropped this 50 issues ago.

It's nice to have unique looking faces again. This feels like it's going to be a filler arc, so I'm rating it as such. Fun little jaunt.

It's ok, not much else to say. I feel like it's trying to do too much at once?

Skippable.

One of the better issues of this arc

This is awkward. The message is delivered very well, but the ride? I feel like the whole thing was rushed to an extent. There were bits and pieces where I could see the potential of Kelly's writing but I don't know why it was unable to come through all the way. I just want to act like these 70 issues never happened. I hope Kelly does what Wells did and throws everything the previous writer did in the trash. I've never been more relieved for a new first issue.

One of the best Spider-Man books in a long time, although that's really not saying much. As a standalone book, it was fine but if I was to rate it on being a #1 honestly it felt a little lackluster. It felt more like a palate cleanser for a new arc in the middle of a run more so than a brand new run. Kelly is getting Peter right IMO, so far. 2 big things I didn't like. The "Nick 'Loves Love' Lowe" editors note was REAL rich coming off the last arc. JRJR was still back in some capacity in the backstory. Sorry JRJR, I'm just not a fan. He can draw plenty better than me, but it's not what I look for in any book I've read with him in the pencils.

Best ASM Kelly has done so far.

Ok, I'm actually semi interested in an amazing Spider-Man story for the first time in far too long. It's not groundbreaking, but at least it's interesting and entertaining.

Solid first arc, loved the art.

Oh how I loathe JRJR. I do have to admit this was some of his best work that I've seen. Well written issue overall.

The hate on this one is a little much. I don't like JRJR or this would be a tad higher. This one was at least fun. It was a nice fight sequence, the banter at the beginning was good, and the inner monologue was decent. It's better than the prior run and I wish it was better, yes, but it's still not bad. Am I settling and accepting this? No, but I'll give a C when it's deserved. Overall average book.

Kelly is doing a great job capturing the inner monologue of Spider-Man. JRJR still can only draw one face.

Actually pretty decent. No ideal what's going on with this Imperial event but it's not bleeding over too much here.

I've been a hater lately but I don't see it on this one; I enjoyed it.

Very mid.

It was... fine. JRJR bring back takes it down some points

I want to be good again, I really do and this showed the potential that it could've but there was a bit of a fumble. First the art. I don't like JRJR's work, but he did a great job on this one. I give credit where it's due. The main plot with Norman was great, if that was the whole book it would've been an 8 or higher. However, they tried to squeeze too much in. It was like a TV show that keeps jumping around to different plot points but nothings really all that connected. It can be an effective story telling tool in the right scenario but not here, it felt too disjointed.

This one was actually an all around solid book

JRJRs art, and the artist hanging 3-4 times, really didn't do well to help the book. I still don't understand why JRJR is on Marvel's flagship hook. I actually enjoyed the writing quite a bit, might've gotten an 8 if it had consistent good art to match.

It was a fine one off story. I wouldn't mind another cameo from Rapid and Screwball was done well. Plus, we actually had good art in ASM.

I have been very critical of ASM and JRJR the last few years, but this book was good, the best in a long time. Other than a few panels I have to give credit to JRJR, some of the best work I've see by him.

Still curious to see how this plays out. Feels a little rushed overall, makes the train if thought of everyone less believable.

Art was superb. I know many haven't been a fun of Zdarsky's run, but I've enjoyed it. I do wish it was better. This one felt like it could've been better if there was a tad bit more exposition.

I liked bringing the detective work back in

I thought this setup nicely, putting Bruce in a position where he has to question what he's doing. Apparently I'm disagreed with but I'm curious to see where this goes.

When I saw this was coming out I was stoked, Biker Mice From Mars was one of my favorites from childhood. The art was great, really leaning into what we're familiar with. The story... it was a little disjointed. There was a lot of bouncing around and the dialogue could've been better. Its only 4 issues long, but I'm undecided if I'm going to get the rest of it, but if you were a fan as a kid this was a fun little bit of nostalgia.

I'm enjoying the overall humor in the book. The frustration of trying to assist, being continually blocked, and having to deal with it is fun.

Art did a great job helping to tell the story

This one started really strong but kind of fumbled the last couple pages. It wasn't bad at the end, I just wanted a little more out of what they set up.

Fun read. Loved the art, they did an amazing job with Black Cat's expressions

I got what I expected out of this book and run, and I'm fine with that.

Very event gimmicky but a fun read nonetheless

This was just plan fun. The tag team gimmick was interesting and well done. Assuming there's a catch for the next round considering the last page reveal, excited to see what happens.

I had no idea this was coming out, saw it on the shelf and was like "oh we're going back?" The art it still jaw dropping and the story was very well done. I don't have room in my pull for it but I'm going to make room.

When Die ended I was content and didn't feel the need to go back. This approach has changed my mind.

This is likely the best #1 I have ever read, I'm very excited to see where this goes. "For every storyteller is a liar, trickster, and traitor. Our first allegiance is always to the tale. To trust us is to risk your very heart. Understand ye yet? You will."

Another great book. Awesome art in the book and an awesome cover by Alex Ross.

Fun book, I disagree with the critics.

Thor vs Zues? Yes please.

He can't keep getting away with it. He got away with it again. He can't keep getting away with it. He got away with it again. This book was brilliant, I enjoyed reading each page 3 times. He got away with it again.

Wild setup for what I presume starts the 2nd half of this rub. Curious to see where this goes.

If you're just getting into comics or know someone who is interested in comics, this is a great starting place for future fans of Wolverine. I'm no wolverine expert, but I didn't learn too much from this book, a lot of rehashing what we already knew. Again, if you're unfamiliar it's great. Otherwise it's just a jog down memory lane.

Good action, Miles going through it at the end, and I love how Vicentini draws Hobgoblin.

Filler/transition issues are hard to rate. For what it was, it was great. But since it really just felt like a placeholder until a possible blood hunt tie in, it couldn't be much more.

Meh. It's primarily just a tie in.

Seems like Blood Hunt may be a cool event, but not interested enough to get more.

It's basically a setup issue for whatever is coming.

Main story is a great standalone read. Primary plot is only addressed by a few pages at the end.

I'm not huge on the vampire thing but this issue was cool.

What started as an action packed fight turned into a heart twisting conversation.

Deadpool is involved so there's all the zaniness you would (or wouldn't?) expect)

Great action sequences early on

I didn't realize this was Ziglar's last book for this run. Overall it was just solid. It definitely had its peeks but the valleys weren't very low. Rabble is a solid addition to Miles rogue gallery. Well done Ziglar.

It was fine. Start of a new arc, I'd be more excited if I knew anything about the Ric era since we're surprisingly going back there, but I dropped the book during it.

Retcon or reveal, not sure. As a stand-alone book it was good, but a "this character has been there the whole time" angle is almost never good. I appreciate Taylor trying to redeem the good parts of the Ric era, but I'd be even happier if Ric is never mentioned again.

Setup for the rest of the arc, excited to see where this goes.

I'd rate it higher but when stories of any kind take this angle they never sit with me well and just bother me, which I guess could be the point.

Last page is an interesting idea, but I can see it happening. Heartless really does have Nightwing in a predicament. I'm enjoying the journey.

This run by Taylor as a whole has been great, I'm sad to see it coming to an end. Fallen Grayson has been a great arc as well.

It's hard to finish a run right and tie everything together. This wasn't perfect, but it did a really good job. It was a page turner for me, for the right reasons. Hopefully the next run doesn't take a lead from the Wells run on ASM.

Great start! Taylor's run was going to be hard to follow and I'm glad it wasn't thrown in the trash and there seems to be some continuity going on here. Art and colors were solid, but the scenes in the dark were outstanding. I'm looking forward to seeing where this run goes.

The new team is starting off well

I'm loving the black and white art for the Zanni scenes.

A lot and nothing happened at the same time?

This is a weird one. Like, I enjoyed it but at the same time nothing happened?

I'm going to keep praising the art

I think the build and wait was worth it, very well done. The art is perfect for what they're trying to do as well.

Ha.

I like the art, but I think Soy's was better for what they were trying to do with this arc.

World building for the new "season" of Saga. Getting off to a good start already. I love this book but these long breaks are killing me.

It's a great twist to end the season, but most of the book is the announcement and then 15 pages of everyone reaching in short panel shots. It makes sense the way they did it, it just doesn't lead to an exciting read post announcement.

I'm enjoying the adventure. Nothing ground breaking but pretty fun.

Still fun, will tune in to see the ending in #5.

Fun/goofy Silk run.

I don't agree with the low scores. Good book, good starting point. Interesting in the ways they're relating to old Gwen.

Fun issue, if I had room in my pull I'd finish the arc.

It's not good, sorry. The plot is so rushed and uses bad stereotypical tropes. The art literally has a template from the cartoon and it barely uses it, granted this is better than other issues. I love the old cartoon, this nostalgia bait and doesn't live up to the series. The only reason I got this one is because it was supposed to be a 4 issue miniseries and I thought this was the let one. Unsure if I'll get the 5th to complete the series or put the first 4 in the donate pile.

Idea - great, I wanted closure on this series. Success of execution? Debatable. The character voices were good, but the story itself didn't sit amazingly with me. And again, we had a template for the art, years of the show, and it's not what we got.

I don't love the sidekick idea, but Spider-Boy is a fun character. Nice story.

It's a bunch of compiled stories form different authors. I thought we were getting a story arc. It's fine, but these types of books aren't my thing.

Got this since Reign 2 was coming out, even though it seemed to be controversial that a sequel was coming. The art is weird, but it fit the vibes of the story. Interesting premise. My only issue is this doesn't quite feel like the Peter Parker we know, but it's technically an "else world" type story so I give some lenience.

This definitely has a vibe and it's sticking to it. Again, art is weird but it fits the story. This is dealing with some dark topics, and we still don't know find out what happened. You can see she's clearly younger than Peter, so it happened awhile ago. You presume this is what broke him down to this level. JJJ's character fulfills his purpose and fits right in for what the author is going for, loud obnoxious old man shouting things from his porch. This old guy is on to something though.

I want to give it a higher score but admittedly some things just don't make sense here. The reveal of how MJ dies? Oof. This makes it a lot more understandable as to why Peter is so broken. My issue is, Peter is always the one to rise up from the pain, the punishment. Here, he's given in. His body almost has a kind of its own but his heart isn't in it. Doc Oc. Oh Doc Oc. I feel like they just wanted to include him. He's use as a driver to get us to the MJ reveal, but he really didn't do anything. He was just a weirdo. I'm assuming a like from this is where they got the Superior Spider-Man idea. Lastly, I get why Peter wants to give up but his approach was, interesting.

The Sandman arc here is depressing, but a well written depressing. We finally see part of Peter's heart wake up thanks to a near death experience and a "visit" from MJ. My biggest problem is it's hard for me to see the world where Peter actually pushes that button.

I feel like everything they're trying to do is just to shock you, it's too much. If the last page wasn't what it was I probably would've dropped it.

Fun little side book.

Fun but kind of meh.

Picked up this and 19 on a whim, I've been surprisingly pleased.

Damn girl.

Loved the art!

For a filler type side issue, quite good.

Still not sure what exactly is going on

Held off on getting this, finally broke down and did it and I have no regrets.

Decent read, clearly a buildup for the next arc.

I get what they were trying to do but the execution wasn't there. This one was kind of just all over the place.

It's fine

That last page is nasty, gross nasty. I feel like the church of blood is a little over used but I'm glad he's doing something which, right now, appears to be different. Stills interested to see where this is going. Love the art.

Needs more punctuation.

Annuals can be an excuse to sell an expensive book, but this is one of the best comics I've ever read. I wish other annals were given the amount of care this book was given. For anyone with any level of interest in Donna Troy should definitely this is easily a must read. Bonus, you don't have to be reading the current to pick this up, it just adds a smidge more context. Very well done Phil Jimenez.

Lots of action, and highly questioning a decision from Optimus..

I read and reread multiple times, but I couldn't completely comprehend what was happening. Last 3-4 pages I understood, and something did happen. I was hyped for this, with how good ultimate Spider-Man was I was hoping they'd be able to ride some momentum in this event and finish his story on a high note. Here's to hoping things pick up in the next issue.

Great world building

No angsty irrational responses!?! Wonderful

I'm not reading every book that comes out, but this has to be a top 5 book.

Still the best Spider-Man book on the market

Zero action scenes in this book, all drama. It was outstanding and I loved every page.

I love this series, another great book.

One of the best books I've read in years. I don't give 10s often, this deserves it.

Definitely a step back from the prior issue with the new level set.

Brilliant. Bloody brilliant. I literally laughed out loud at the twist because of how good it was.

Another ultimate entry to the best Spider book on the shelves.

A lot of the complaints on this book seem to be from people who clearly haven't been reading any of the ultimate Spider-Man books. You should be, it's one of the best books out there right now.

Ok story. Capped it off well

Interesting choices in that one minou.

Sets up status quo for the arc with a new zone and interesting twist at the end. If you've been on the fence on staying on, back off the book says issue 36 will be the end.

It feels like they were told they need to speed up the story if they want to finish it, a lot of information that could've been drawn out has been thrown at us really fast. I believe there are only 2 issues left, I'm committed to seeing the end at this point.

5 issues left after this one. Interesting turns in this one.