Absolute Batman #1

Absolute Batman #1 kicks the door down to introduce Bruce Wayne and Gotham City, unlike anything you've seen before. Scott Snyder and Nick Dragotta masterfully lay the groundwork for an exciting new era in Batman comics where anything goes. Read Full Review

In Absolute Batman #1, Scott Snyder and Nick Dragotta went all in to make an absolutely worthwhile issue. Working-class by day, spiked-up suit by night, this Batman is an underdog fighting against an impossible system, the odds ever stacked against him. It's a story that everybody needs right now. It also works well even if it's your first-ever comic. Read Full Review

Absolute Batman #1 is brave and it's bold. From the outset Scott Snyder has a clear vision for the Absolute Universe which somehow already feels established even on page 1. His intentions are clear, the world is accessible and coherent giving readers the chance to just enjoy the story. Nick Dragotta draws the hell out of this gargantuan new Batman. Consider me hooked. Read Full Review

Absolute Batman #1 heralds a new hardcore world. This comic builds a brand new Batman, brand new Gotham, and brand new everything. Snyder’s writing is brave and bold, telling stories that can only be told in this universe without connections or shackles. Read Full Review

Absolute Batman #1 is an audacious take on 85 years of the Caped Crusader's history that feels familiar while also housing a myriad of new and clever takes on classic characters. Read Full Review

This first issue already makes this one of the most exciting new comics to come out of DC in a long time. Read Full Review

Scott Snyder's return to Gotham takes readers on a brutally engaging start. The writing mixes up classic lore with a more modern feel. Its' result never misses its' mark with drama and suspense. Dragotta, Martin and Cowles leave readers in awe with the imagery of the new Dark Knight. If this is any indication of the rest of the Absolute Universe, fans are in for another epic journey. Read Full Review

Absolute Batman #1 sets a high bar for the rest of the Absolute Universe titles. If they can all be at this level, DC fans could be in for a cant miss journey. Read Full Review

Absolute Batman #1 manages the impossible, reinventing the wheel into something new while still rolling forward in a familiar fashion. I am not sure where Snyder and Dragotta will go from here. However, I am quite excited to be along for the ride. Read Full Review

There are a lot of characters that we know stuffed into these pages, but each one is turned about one or two degrees the other way. Scott Snyder sets up a lot on the table. Agent Alfred, Bruce being friends with what would be his rogues gallery in another universe, and more. Read Full Review

After all the gushing reviews, I was worried that it would be a comic solely for hardcore Bat-fans, or another example of a book everyone loves but me.But this is absolutely remarkable. Read Full Review

Absolute Batman turns the Batman lore on its head, offering a fresh, compelling take on the character we know and love. Snyder and Dragotta craft a Batman for 2024 that feels both revolutionary and true to the essence of the hero. Reimaginings can be hit or miss in the comic book world, but with this creative team, DC has struck gold. Be sure to grab a copy of Absolute Batman #1 while you can, and get ready for an exciting new direction in the DC Universe. Read Full Review

Dragotta delivers some beautifully detailed art throughout the issue. I love the gritty visual style of the world and its characters. The action looks amazing and I love the practical look of everything Bruce uses in the story. Read Full Review

Absolute Batman #1 is an outstanding beginning to a brand new beginning. Scott Snyder and Nick Dragotta do an excellent job with the presentation of the Absolute Universe version of Gotham City. Everything is so picture perfect that you can't help but want to read the next issue right away. This is everything both new and long-time fans could want. Read Full Review

This is a solid first issue that does a good job of setting the story up. I enjoyed the book but am curious as to how this more working-class version of Bruce Wayne has managed to fund all of his studies as well as all of the hardware that he uses. Obviously there are a few clues as to how this has worked as we get references to Oswald Cobblepot and we also meet Killer Crock who runs the gym where Bruce Works out at. Quite how Cobblepot and other well-known Batman villains will get used in this alternative story as yet remains to be seen, but it will be interesting to find out if they best guesses about them will turn out to be true. Read Full Review

Absolute Batman #1 is a banger of a first issue that introduces readers to a new-ish kind of Batman, Alfred and Gotham City. Scott Snyder's knack for hard-hitting action and drama is on full display, and Nick Dragotta's art sings during the big fight. That said, Absolute Batman is almost too similar to regular Batman, so you may wonder why creating an alternate version was necessary.9/10 Read Full Review

The return of what appears to be some formidable adversary from Batman's past, adds a layer of intrigue and danger to the story. This confrontation serves as a reminder of the challenges Batman will face in this new world that seem familiar to what we remember but with a unique twist. So, is Absolute Batman #1 worth reading? For fans of Batman and dark, gritty superhero stories, this issue is a must-read. Snyder and Dragotta have crafted a compelling and thought-provoking tale that reimagines the character in a brutal and unforgiving world. While the lack of familiar trappings might be jarring for some readers, the focus on character development and the exploration of Batman's humanity make this a worthwhile journey. Overall, Absolute Batman #1 is a powerful and thought-provoking reimagining of Batman, setting the stage for a compelling new series. Read Full Review

Absolute Batman #1 is the Batman comic for the kids that blast She Wants Revenge while watching their Bachelor's in Public Policy diploma accumulate dust in their mom's basement. (So, basically Jonathan Hickman and Marco Checchetto's Ultimate Spider-Man for Goth kids.) That's weirdly specific, but Scott Snyder, Nick Dragotta, and Cowles craft a new take on the Dark Knight that's civically minded while also having the best extended action sequence in years. Car chase scenes in The Batman and Batman Begins, eat your heart out! The added page count creates a flow for the fighting while still allowing time to flesh out the book's cast and world. Purists may thumb their noses at this title, but Batman is character that thrives with rebirths and reinvention. I just can't wait to see what cool shit Snyder and Dragotta do with him next! Read Full Review

Not a grand reinvention so much as just a good, solid, entertaining Batman comic, with some of the major players shuffled around into new roles. Should be a fun read. Read Full Review

Absolute Batman #1 is a bold, unapologetic vision that makes it stand out. It doesn't just tweak the formula; it demolishes and rebuilds something new. Snyder's writing is a masterclass in balancing intense action with moments of genuine character development. Dragotta's art is a perfect match dynamic, gritty, and overflowing with detail. Read Full Review

Absolute Batman #1 is not quite the home run debut that Ultimate Spider-Man was, instead offering a mixture of interesting concepts and art with well-tread executions. Snyder offers nuggets of dynamic changes to the Bat-mythos throughout the issue yet struggles to create an interesting villain or thematic spine that strikes hard and fast. In contrast, Dragottas art comes out swinging, finding the right balance of new and old in the design work. The idea of brickhouse Bruce was treated as a joke in the lead-up to this issue but is executed brilliantly in the physical space of the page. When combined with Martins color, a real sense of harmony is struck in the depiction of Gotham as a place of terror and beauty. Despite some rocky narrative elements, Absolute Batman has enough potential to sell the first volley of the Absolute Universe. Read Full Review

Absolute Batman #1 goes out of its way to differentiate itself from its “normal” counterpart by subverting reader expectations with twists on classic Batman tropes, emphasizing the universe's distinctive tone. The story's over-the-top approach to its violent world manages to avoid coming across as self-parody thanks to the sincerity of Scott Snyder's writing and impressive artwork by Nick Dragotta. Read Full Review

While I'm hesitant to declare the concept of Absolute Batman a homerun, I will say that the first issue was very good. Snyder's story delivers on his imaginative "what if ? premise. Dragotta's art compliments the story well, breathing life into what was likely a hefty script. Overall, Absolute Batman #1 accomplished its major goal: it has me excited for the next issue. Read Full Review

Absolute Batman #1 is a great introduction to Bruce Wayne and the world around him. Snyder has introduced a more brutal Gotham than I've read before, and I'm eager to see where it goes and what new relationships can be forged along the way. Read Full Review

Overall, Absolute Batman #1 is technically a well executed and crafted first issue. There is a question of "why we should care about Bruce and why is Alfred more interesting? While the Easter Eggs and references should reassure the reader, there isn't a strong enough core concept for this version of Batman to bring me back. Maybe the violent, over the top approach is what some readers are looking for. Or, perhaps, it's what appeals to the creatives in the Absolute Universe. I don't think the majority of fans are looking for a recapitulation of the same ideas that Alan Moore and Frank Miller first utilized in the '80's and '90's. DC seems to have a desire to reinvent the wheel instead of just telling great stories that move established characters forward. Read Full Review

This book is without question well put together, with a script that twists and turns and looks to subvert the original premise into something new and different, which leads me to ask why bother with using Batman? If you want something new, create something new! The problem with that is that there would be no playing on existing tropes, no chance to to be oh so clever and pretentious, so much cleverer than the the main Batman who is stuck in his own continuity. However, no matter how well crafted, I really just don't care. Absolute Batman, more like Absolute bonkers! Read Full Review

motorik

Oct 08, 2024

Absolutely brilliant. For those disenfranchised with the Chip Zdarsky run, look no further. An intelligent and brutal Batman. I cannot wait to read more.

davepete

Oct 09, 2024

Now that is a comic book. Wow! I'm all in.

Linkush

Oct 09, 2024

Yeah… THIS GOES SO HARD!

+ Like • Comments (2)

• Likes (3)

• motorik
• fthissite
• Figgs95

RKS - Oct 19, 2024

That's the problem...When you try too hard you come off all wrong. Glad you liked it but for me it's a hard fail.

Linkush - Oct 19, 2024 (edited)

I mean, yeah, it’s a lot different than the original so it’s a given there’s going to be people who won’t enjoy it. I myself find this very refreshing. And very cool!

fthissite

Oct 09, 2024

Banger.

Deep Six

Oct 11, 2024

This f***ed HARD. My goodness

Jawnyblaze

Oct 11, 2024

Absolutely brilliant. Great art, great writing, great setting and plot, one of the best first books I've read in a while.

stefanomjr

Oct 12, 2024

Enjoyed the title. Scott is writing another story based on personal fears and worries, but this time those fears are also through the lense of his own children. A modern story that links this young Bruce being shaped by a different type of trauma. Scott is turning the Gotham we know upside down but it still feels relatable as the place we've known over the last 85 years. I didn't know Nick's work at all before this. Scott, in an interview, described the style as a cross between Mazzucchelli and Manga. Nick, in an interview, explained how a trip to Japan heavily influenced his style and designs in this book. I'm enjoying the sequential storytelling and the way the action is broken down into such kinetic energy... those speed l ines and camera angles are fabulous! I also enjoyed the way Bruce's reveal twist was handled, not once, but twice. Very cinematic. If there is one critique, it's the colors. The original B&W artwork losses its dynamic kinetic energy when the colors wash over all those glorious speed lines! Book just went into 3rd printing. So far so good more

+ Like • Comments (1)

• Likes (3)

• motorik
• fthissite
• Figgs95

RKS - Oct 19, 2024

This run is dollar bin bound. Enjoy this run because it's doomed from the get go,

derbycomics

Oct 12, 2024

There’s been SO much talk about this book that I struggled to put my thoughts together. Scott Snyder, Nick Dragotta, Frank Martin, & Clayton Cowles delivered what will likely go down as one of the biggest, most consequential Batman #1s in the character’s storied history. What was left to say? Instead of trying to one-up the platitudes, I figured I’d talk about a few of the aspects that struck me most. First off, this retelling isn’t a gimmick. Sure there are exaggerated aspects, look no further than our boy’s thiqq new physique, but these pieces aren’t WHY the story is being told. They’re just insanely awesome details that add to the experience. What Snyder does so brilliantly is strip Bruce down to the core ethos that has motivated him for decades — revenge. There is a singular moment in his life that shapes his worldview & defines his life’s mission. This is on full display in this first issue & now Bruce must find new means of achieving his goals without the unlimited resources of a rich playboy. There’s a rawness here that hasn’t existed in any Elseworld/Black Label/alternate universe retelling of Batman so far. And holy crap the art! Dragotta’s use of unconventional paneling is so ingenious, so effective, & keeps readers disoriented ever so slightly as we’re discovering what this new world is all about. It’s a masterclass in visual storytelling that only exists when a writer & artist are fully aligned & trust each other completely. While I love the Chonky Knight’s look, I may love the design for his cape & its abilities even more. Its such a smart way to capture bat-like motion & reveals that where Bruce lacks in financial resources, his ingenuity & smarts are off the charts. There are so many other things I loved about this book that I could fill several posts’ character limits with. But I’ll end with something I’ve heard say a few times. My favorite thing about this book is that it is a comic story. It can only exist in comic form. And THAT is why I read comics. more

Martin

Oct 19, 2024

Believe the hype! 
 Absolute Batman is 100% what everyone says it is, easily one of the best comics I have read in a long time. Snyder delivered the goods with an assist from artist Nick Dragotta (who I am now a huge fan of). This was an excellently paced story … not too fast and not too slow - it was literally perfectly paced. The choice to reveal this new character …no this is NOT the Batman you are familiar with … Snyder used an outside character to reveal Bruce Wayne to the audience … and this was a brilliant decision on his part. That one factor pulled EVERYTHING together into a “page-turning highly” enjoyable read. Snyder took everything you know about Batman and turned it on its side for a brand new experience that had a tinge of familiarity. He reformatted many of the villains and other Gotham citizens into all new characters that have completely different relationships with Bruce and the book is all the better for it. I don’t want to spoil a single moment as the less you know the better. The only drawback that I can see is what’s coming next … this world built for Absolute Batman should be just for Batman … but I know Absolute Superman and Absolute Wonder Woman will connect with this title and I feel that has the potential to throw off this perfect vibe. Even worse - this may all be rolling into that silly Darkseid story that was introduced in the All-In Special, if that’s where all this is going - I will be very disappointed. However for right now - if you can find a copy go out grab it and read it … do not let it be spoiled for you. more

Figgs95

Oct 25, 2024

Honestly the most enjoyable batman read for me in a very long time. I love everything about this new take on Bruce Wayne & his new outfit is so badass! Alot of brutal action and I can't wait to read more. This first issue was a 10/10 for me.

Aesopjer

Oct 27, 2024

Scott Snyder AND Nick Dragotta?!? Hey this brought me back into comics and it’s one helluva reintroduction. What intrigues me the most, is that his traditional enemies are childhood friends, so now I’m curious to see as the series goes on, are we going to witness them turn evil? Anyway I’m ‘All In’ on this ride.

Moriaen

Dec 09, 2024

Absolute Batman is a bold reimagining of the Batman mythos. Since the Dark Knight has always dwelled in the shadows, this Absolute universe is a perfect fit. Scott Snyder masterfully reworks the mythology in intriguing ways, while Nick Dragotta's energetic art practically leaps off the page.

Toonstrack

Oct 10, 2024

Excellent. A great, exhilarating, fun comic. Written by a writer whos been on thus rodeo track before. Drawn by an artist in his prime and knowing exactly what he wants and colored by a colorist in perfect unison. Everything here works. It doesnt strive to reinvent the wheel but it does strive to give you a good time and it exceeds in doing so. Im not concerned about any of the changes til I see how they affect the story. As they are they don't bother me. Bring more of this!

Robert Everson

Oct 12, 2024

Great first issue!

Ryan

Oct 19, 2024

Strong start

Hex

Oct 21, 2024

Nothing much to say that hasn't been said but there is something comforting about reading a good Snyder Bat-book after so long. It's damn near perfect. A wonderful introduction into a new version of Batman that already feels fleshed out. I can't wait to see more from all of the characters in this interpretation.

ResearchReader

Dec 22, 2024

Classic easy way to get to cheer for the hero. Create comically evil villains and have the hero go to town. Honestly it was cathartic the way Batman ruined them. So I enjoyed that classic trope. -.5 for the epilogue. That seems like a lame Joker intro but I hope to be proven wrong. Solid art.

KevinSD

Oct 09, 2024

Ok.... First off... Scott Snyder did what he do best... Concoct a Good Story. Though, funny. Reading this issue felt like I'm ready a Spider Man x Punisher mashup as Batman story. Bruce Wayne living a normal life (ala Parker's Luck) with his very alive Mother (ala Aunt May). Though his father is dead (ala Uncle Ben). For Bruce's night life, he becomes the Batman but very Punisher-esque hardcore with cool grappling cape and a huge axe. The relation between Bruce and Pennyworth was kind of predictable, very Movie-ish... They'll start as rival then becomes partners, so on and so forth.... Let's all see... Plus the tease of Joker as a corporate mogul (ala Norman Osborn). All in all, the story premise is very familiar... very S pider-Manish, but I like it none the less.. more

+ Like • Comments (1)

• Likes (3)

• motorik
• myconius
• fthissite

myconius - Oct 10, 2024

I really liked your summation. I'm going to have to try re-reading this. I was just disappointed that it didn't really vibe as a "Batman" comic to me. If it had been written as a brand new original character I probably would have enjoyed it a lot more.

daspidaboy

Oct 09, 2024

I'm shocked by how good this is. I thought Scott Snyder was here just for the money and he wanted to focus on his indie projects. plus, I was tired of his huge exposition dumps. but this was solid. I'm not a fan of Nick Dragotta's art because I think it's bland. But maybe it's because of the coloring but it works here. It's very brutal and gels well, and the suit has grown on me. This issue shows why Scott Snyder is the best modern Batman writer of all time in my opinion. Comic book fans are eating good with ultimate Spider-Man and Absolute Batman. I hope we keep on getting great projects like these

+ Like • Comments (1)

• Likes (3)

• motorik
• Jawnyblaze
• fthissite

TJMB3891 - Oct 10, 2024

If you like Nick Dragotta's art here then you'd love East of West by him and Hickman.

Gophfacekillah

Oct 09, 2024

Snyder is king of strong starts. Pace is great and covers a lot quickly without feeling like all exposition. All the characters seem super interesting. Only issue so far is Bruce may be the least interesting character so far.

SuperheroesAR

Oct 12, 2024

بداية ممتازة مع نسخة جديدة من باتمان مختلفة عن اي نسخة سابقة بشكل كبير ونظرة جديدة على الشخصية نجح فيها سكوت سنايدر بتقديمها بشكل غير متوقع مع هذا العالم جديد بكل تفاصيله والتلميحات واكيد المفاجأة بالصفحات الاخيرة رسم دراقوتا ساعد بتقديم النسخة الجديدة بشكل مرعب وعزز سرد القصة من الناحية البصرية مع تصاميم الشخصيات المبهر

TomTom

Oct 19, 2024

I just finished reading Absolute Batman #1, and I’ve got to say, it really impressed me. Scott Snyder and Nick Dragotta did a fantastic job reimagining Bruce Wayne as a working-class engineer rather than a billionaire. It makes him feel more grounded and relatable. The story follows Alfred as he investigates the Party Animals, a criminal gang, only to find Batman already on the case. This version of Batman has a different set of challenges and resources, and that makes the action feel more intense and real. The artwork is stunning, and the story keeps you hooked. Overall, Absolute Batman #1 is a great read that reinvents Batman while staying true to what makes him such an iconic character. Loved every page.

maljoss

Oct 10, 2024

I haven't been this excited about a Batman comic since Norm Breyfoggle was a regular penciler on Detetcive. This comic was really good - had a Dark Knight vibe that cannot be coincidental. The visual storytelling was top notch. I'm not familiar with Nick Dragotta, but this was impressive. The colors were a bit dull, but overall the art was just fine. The story was also fine. Well paced, good world building, decent dialogue, characterization was fine. I genuinely hope they do something different and new. Change everything, don't just rehash the greatest hits. The one disappointment was the introduction of the "Joker" - henceforth to be known as "The Joker Who Doesn't Laugh". Too soon. You can't drop The Joker in the first issue. You gotta ea rn The Joker. Curious to see where this goes. more

+ Like • Comments (2)

• Likes (1)

• davepete

davepete - Oct 10, 2024

Joker appears in 2 stories in Batman (1940) #1, so maybe Scott felt the need for him to appear in the first issue, even if his storyline doesn't begin quite yet.

maljoss - Oct 11, 2024

I'm not going to begrudge Mr. Snyder his plot points. I'm just sick of the Joker. I'd have loved for this series to go 30 issues before introducing him. The whole "Batman Who Laughs" / "Joker Who Doesn't Laugh" thing also rubbed me the wrong way. It's a small quibble for what was, largely, an excellent comic.

Screaming Enigma

Dec 22, 2024

Definitely an intriguing start here. This is a lot of Alfred, which is certainly a choice initially. However, I think that it worked nicely as a way to introduce Bruce and give his origins. Furthermore, I think we got to see a solid amount of Bruce as himself and as Batman here, so I can't complain too much. I feel as though Snyder is building an interesting world here and I'm definitely looking forward to seeing where things go. Dragotta's art was good as well, although I do think that it worked best when he drew the larger characters such as Black Mask and Batman, himself.

Psycamorean

Oct 14, 2024

Probably one of the biggest issues of the year. You can tell by how some people have reacted poorly to it. I even saw some people outright lying about the issue to hate it more. Wonderful. I liked it. I do have some bothersome worries about it. That epilogue was quite a sour note to end on, especially after what I thought was a really satisfying twist at the end of the issue proper. It makes me question things a bit. We know from All-In that this is a universe where Darkseid wins and everything is topsy-turvy. Heroes have been stripped of everything, and villains seemingly are doing pretty well for themselves. And that makes me think two things: 1, Isn't this just another attempt at the Dark Multiverse, but boiled down a bit better? And 2 , is constraining your new universe to this dichotomy, as this issue presents it, ultimately going to limit this universe's potential to stand on its own? more

Simon DelMonte

Nov 11, 2024

I have so many qualms and questions about this - is this just another Elseworlds? Is this just another IP grab? Is this sustainable? - but the art is great and the writing is great. Sometimes I forget that Snyder is really good at this game, even if he's also had a tendency to bite off more than he can chew. For now, this plays to his strengths and is just compelling enough to justify sticking around for a while.

Williamflipper

Dec 18, 2024

It feels like a dark night return meets manga

YEARofTheCollector

May 30, 2025

The hype was well granted for this book. Everything about this series feels well thought out and planned. When it comes to the supporting characters, everyone has been shuffled around. I don't think is going to be as simple as the bad guys are now the good guys either, but I'm very invested in seeing how this new world altered by Darkseid molded their lives. As far as the Batman goes, wow! This is different, in a good way. This Dark knight is a force. His quite strong, tactical, precise and prepared. As for Bruce, he's young but he's quite dedicated to this life. Snyder came out swinging for the fences with this series and I can't wait to see more. The art is a perfect fit for what Snyder wants to do. Nick Dragotta understood the assignment given to him by Snyder and Frank Martin provides the aesthetics to define this new Gotham. Their creativity and boldness combined screams at you in every page, this is a new world, you may recognize it, but you don't know it yet. I'm excited the absolute universe. more

Chris Y

Oct 06, 2025

Batman looks ridiculous. The logo looks ridiculous. The art is rough. The writing feels disjointed. Snyder and Dragotta don't seem to care too much whether their creation is perfect. Maybe that's why I like it. This book shouldn't work, but for some reason it does.

Tempra16v2.0Turbo

Oct 09, 2024

I'm not engaged, yet.

Underhill

Oct 10, 2024

I am tired of the constant variants but hopefully DC at least sees what Marvel is doing with the Ultimates and lets this one cook. The art is cool, and the story so far is interesting enough. I think it’s best to temper expectations amidst the typically fanboy hysteria that comes out with any new event. Recognize DC has a tendency to pump and dump. Future State, Death Metal, etc.

fzanca

Oct 12, 2024

I'm not sure why we need these elsewhere titles, but they are here nonetheless. We have a Batman who has no problem maiming utilizing a heavy weapon attached to his chest that would hinder his movement. Then we are introduced to an Alfred who's working for a clandestine organization against the "Party Animals," which is one of the stupidest names I've ever heard. I wasn't as enamored with this book as some people. They only created this because their regular books aren't selling. How about putting some better writers on your main Batman titles and giving him his money back?My Comic Review Channel - https://youtu.be/8biQU5RaBIA?si=Id8vjMPF99F081tu That might be a start. My Comic Review Channel - https://youtu.be/8biQU5RaBIA?si=Id8vjMPF99F 081tu more

TSMack

May 13, 2025

(Cover Date: December, 2024)

BesottedGeekPod

Oct 14, 2024

Good world building and some cool moments, along with the usual Snyder groaners (we get that you know Batman’s creators, Scott). The art is good, yet I’m not a fan of some of the character designs. Hate the cape. I’m going to throw this out there since I haven’t seen it yet: Mad Hatter involvement.

Kenjamin

Dec 13, 2024

Art: 3.5/5 Story: 3.5/5 Total: 7/10

Starman123

Oct 11, 2024

Scott Snyder has written some exceptional Batman comics. This is not one of them. Nick Dragotta does a pretty good job with the art, he definitely has a unique style. I feel like I have read this before, however. I think it was called The Dark Knight Returns by a guy called Frank Miller, which was fantastic. This seems like the same recipe only Bruce Wayne is young instead of old. Also, I don’t feel as though we got to know much about Bruce Wayne/Batman in this issue. It mostly takes place through the eyes of Alfred, which is not all that interesting. I was kind of wondering what was up with the big blocky bat on his chest. Though the reveal was not all that interesting. Will I buy issue 2? Most likely, but this title is on a short leash for me. It is definitely readable but not a unique take on the character. more

myconius

Oct 10, 2024

***Cons*** -Goofy Anime-looking art (Batman looks ridiculous) -Too Subversive (This was built for the first time read. i doubt the twists will hold up upon re-reads) -Too Deconstructive (There is only so much you can bend and deconstruct characters before they are NO LONGER the same character. I'll avoid going into spoilers, but you'll know who I'm referring to right from the start of the comic) -Yet another Brutal Batman that kills (At least this killer-Batman is different in that he stabs and hacks his enemies to bloody bits) -SOOOO EDGY!!! (I am sick and tired of grimdark edgelord comics) ***Pros*** -At least its not by Tom King -Thankfully not by Chip Zdarsky either -At least this Batman doesn't weigh a buck and change, and h ave to wear armor to compensate. -Thankfully Scott Snyder refrained from making this as overly-wordy as his prior Batman writing. -At least this Batman hasn't killed anyone with a gun (At least not yet) -The Art is honestly the best part!! There might have been another positive? I just can't think of it right now. I'm going to try re-reading this at some point and see if i feel differently about it later. more

+ Like • Comments (8)

• Likes (4)

• Quinn
• RKS
• Nicetrylaoche
• Starman123

Show all comments

Toonstrack - Oct 10, 2024

They made it explicitly clear that Bruce didn't kill anyone in this book.

myconius - Oct 10, 2024

This "Batman" had just impaled some guy in both his lungs leaving him bleeding out. If he wasn't dead immediately then he soon would be. Same with the guy that had half his arm chopped off. "Batman" saying "No fatalities" .... That line is preposterous after seeing what had just happened.

Quinn - Oct 14, 2024

It’s like this Batman is a bizarro. Old Bruce is rich, this one is poor. Joker is the rich one. Old Bats is lean and linear, this one is a blocky bulk. Old Bruce is orphaned, this one has a parent.

Quinn - Oct 14, 2024

All in all, not very clever. Just do the opposite. Or I could be wrong.

myconius - Oct 14, 2024

Yeah. It really felt like it was trying too hard to be subversive just for the hell of it. Like the flip of Alfred. I rolled my eyes so damn hard! I saw through Scott Snyder's shtick pretty early on. All sizzle but no steak.

Quinn - Oct 14, 2024

Glad you mentioned that. Old Alfred is British gentleman of class and breeding. New Alfred is a blunt instrument. (See Daniel Craig James Bond.)

myconius - Oct 15, 2024

Sadly, DC doesn't seem to have any writers within their current roster that have even so much as a clue on how to write Alfred. One of the best additions to the Bat-mythos, and they seem to do nothing but continually disrespect him.

Toonstrack - Oct 15, 2024

Theres nothing blunt about this Alfred. He is shown to have morals and be on the right side of things, that hasn't changed. Hes also very clearly a gentleman, he just has an edge. Alfred has military expertise even in prime universe. Also Bruce isn't poor. They never said he was poor.

Dave

Oct 09, 2024

I tried to read it and made it to page 6 and just didn’t care to finish, I am going to try to read it again later . Might change my grade later. I just did not care to finish it

+ Like • Comments (11)

• Likes (4)

• Tempra16v2.0Turbo
• Nicetrylaoche
• Quinn
• RKS

Show all comments

TotyGamer - Oct 9, 2024

If you didn't read something (completely), then don't score it. It's simple.

Danilo Silva - Oct 9, 2024

I agree with TotyGamer, actually.

Tempra16v2.0Turbo - Oct 9, 2024

I confess that I found myself counting the remaining pages at one point.

myconius - Oct 10, 2024

This comic really was a chore for me tho get through. The more I read the more disappointed I became. It just did not feel like Batman. But at least it didn't follow the recent pattern of (overly sad Batman) that we have been stuck with since 2016. I'm going to try re-reading this, but I can't say that I'm in a rush to do so.

Dave - Oct 10, 2024

I think being unable to finish the book says a lot about it

davepete - Oct 10, 2024

I can't imagine only reading 6 pages of a 40-page comic you paid $5 for. It's not difficult reading, and the title character shows up on page 17.

myconius - Oct 10, 2024

I have to agree with the reviewer on this one. I've also bought many a single issue that turned out to be such a chore to read that I never bothered to finish them. I've also taken chances buying some $20 (or more) trades that were just not enjoyable at all. They sat in my "To Be Read" pile for years until I finally gave them away.

TotyGamer - Oct 10, 2024

Unable to finish one issue says more about you imo ;)

myconius - Oct 10, 2024

Yeah, It says he's wise to not waste time on something he's not enjoying.

TotyGamer - Oct 10, 2024

Then don't rate it lmao it's not that hard. If you want to score it, you read the complete thing. It's one issue that barely takes time.

myconius - Oct 10, 2024

Agree to disagree. ....or don't agree. .... but disagree nonetheless.

RKS

Oct 19, 2024

Edgelord dogshit. This is more attention than this book deserves. 6 months from now this run will be in the dollar bin and never mentioned again.

dabellwrites

Nov 04, 2024

Nothing really groundbreaking honestly. It's better at hooking the reader than AWW since they had much longer to tell their story. The first issue heavily pulls from Frank Miller going far as the news anchors. and it seems Scott is threading his own Court of Owls, or something like that in there. I can't say much more. It's serviceable.