Green Lantern #1

The biggest question that most readers will have, is how accessible will this new series be. Despite this being a new series, Morrison isn't known for making things simple for the sake of new fans. In comparison to Morrison's other works, this is a great jumping on point for new or lapsed readers. It doesn't shift the paradigm to much for Hal (except for the new blonde in his life?), but instead gets rid of all the excess and boils down to what a Green Lantern is at the core. A space cop dealing with criminals on a galactic scale, there's enough silly silver age homages to make this feel different than what DC is currently publishing. You combine that with Sharp and Oliff on art duties, this is a book that will bring readers back to world of Green Lantern. An amazing debut issue, if you've never read Green Lantern before, now's a perfect time to start. Read Full Review

This is how you kick off a Green Lantern book! Read Full Review

If you've been waiting for a reason to give the ring-slinger another chance, this is the bright light you've been waiting for. Read Full Review

Look, if you knew this book was coming then you already have it. But for those who somehow still are wary then please take my advice and just go for it. Grant Morrison has returned with all of his masterful knowledge and skill in this particular medium, which combined with peerless art and colours from Liam Sharp and Steve Oliff make this an absolute must-read. Get it, read it and prepare for a Green Lantern run that well all be talking about for a long, long time to come. Read Full Review

The Green Lantern is one of those rare superhero comics that arrives seemingly fully formed, already imbued with its own striking personality and point of view. Gorgeously rendered and hauntingly portrayed, this isn't like any Hal Jordan story you've read before " The Green Lantern aims to shed new light on the strange new corners of the DC Universe, and I for one can't wait to dive back into the breach to see what this creative team can deliver. Read Full Review

After months of rumors and high expectations, Grant Morrison makes his explosive return to DC monthly. The combination of Liam Sharp and Steve Oliff on art completely fits the space opera nature of the title, while simultaneously working perfectly with the larger ideas of Morrisons scripts. The Green Lantern is a must buy for fans of Morrison, the Lantern Mythos and comics in general. Read Full Review

"The Green Lantern" #1 is not just a near perfect first issue, but it's also a near perfect superhero comic, and it should delight both fans of the character and the uninitiated alike. Read Full Review

It's still too early to tell whether this run will add to Hal Jordan's legacy or detract from it, but the evidence available leads me to believe that greatness awaits.The Green Lantern (2018-) #1is an impressive first issue. Read Full Review

The next chapter of Hal Jordan's saga begins with Grant Morrison and Liam Sharp. The first issue is promising as Hal Jordan tries to reestablish his life on Earth while keeping his eyes to the sky. Morrison and Sharp seem like they are preparing to put Hal through the ringer and I am anxious to see if Hal is able to survive what they have planned. Read Full Review

With good doses of intergalactic spectacle and bare knuckled grit this debut issue reintroduces readers to the Green Lantern universe without retreading the history that most comics readers are already familiar with. Long time Lantern fans and new readers will find this issue accessible. Read Full Review

Although a little strange at times, this is classic Grant Morrison as he takes Hal Jordan back to basics with his unique Silver Age twist on this classic character, including his existentialist view on what makes this hero tick. Given that there's so much happening in this issue, it probably requires a second read, particularly with the extremely detailed art of Liam Sharp who incorporates a clever layer of 60's psychedelic which was when this character was created. Read Full Review

It's fast-paced, incredibly detailed, and in some places grotesque " a floating finger with a Lantern ring attached and a sentient virus with a particularly disgusting method of communication are just two elements going on in this very busy and cosmic story. Read Full Review

If this first issue is any indication, this new version of Green Lantern will be exactly the type of comic you’ll want to read to get that space-faring fix. And with Morrison in the lead and Sharp on art, you just know it’s going to get weird! Read Full Review

The Green Lantern is a must-buy for Green Lantern Fans. It's fun, its weird, and surprisingly hilarious. If Morrison and Sharp can keep this up we'll have a modern classic on our hands. Read Full Review

From alien lifeforms and far-off planets to a quieter moment with Hal observing the sky, it is distinctive; a relic from a bygone era that feels fresh all the same. Read Full Review

And while I'm putting in requests, I'd like to see some Earthbound adventures - he shouldn't spend all his time on alien worlds. Read Full Review

This issue does plenty of juggling but sets up the series on a path that I want to travel. A solid tweak for old fans and a welcoming new start for those just discovering Green Lantern for the first time. Read Full Review

Morrisonfans are already going to grab this but if you are new to him this is actually a great introduction to the writer and to Green Lantern. It has enough of the Morrison weirdness to feed your jones, yet a surprising grounding in the structure that makes it accessible but unique too. It's also all beautifully illustrated. This book is a definite buy. Read Full Review

The Green Lantern #1 is a solid start to the series. I don't think it will be as mind-blowing as people are expecting, but I also do not think that is what Morrison is going for, either. It fits his idea of "space cop drama." That has me really interested to continue this series to see what predicaments he puts Hal Jordan in. It also helps the art is marvelous in The Green Lantern #1. Sharp and Orzechowski bring a visual flair to The Green Lantern #1 that is a pure delight to look at. Read Full Review

The introduction of the issue was a little clunky and scattered, but the overall concept of the issue was sound. Read Full Review

Admittedly, I had to read this comic twice before I felt like I had a solid understanding of things. But trust me, if you can relax your continuity filters a bit you will happily take in the majesty that is Liam Sharp and Grant Morrison's The Green Lantern. Sharp and Morrison delivered a fun, wacky, psychedelic space cop experience that's by all appearances going to take Hal Jordan back to the core of what being a Green Lantern is all about. Read Full Review

The Green Lantern #1 brings the franchise back to basics, but there's plenty of flavor to set the book apart. Read Full Review

I've long enjoyed the Green Lantern property and all the creativity that comes from it but moreso when it spends its time away from Earth and most of those with it. Hence my enjoyment of the lesser known books or the Corps books themselves. While Grant Morrison is bringing us back to working with Hal directly here, it works as I think he has a good enough handle on a way to push the character and do something interesting with him. And even if that falls a bit flat there's still everything else that he has going into motion here that will fascinate and expands. Liam Sharpe has long been a favorite of mine in the art department and he delivers a fantastic looking book here with Oliffe's color work, which thankfully doesn't feel like it overdoes it on the green in the way some colorists do. It's a solid opening that has me coming back for more. Read Full Review

I will definitely be reading this series going forward, it feels like a decent jumping on point for readers unfamiliar with concepts, as it may turn you onto some new facets of GL lore. Read Full Review

But regardless of where the story goes and if my prediction is right or wrong, this is a must-see new direction for Hal Jordan. Its a back-to-basics story for Hal Jordan and it will be refreshing to see him out of the angsty rut he was in during the end of New 52 era and away from the end of the universe style plots that Vendetti had him wrapped up in. The issue does lose points for the prologue style cadence of the opening but, overall, its an exciting emerald dawn for the Green Lantern Corps. Read Full Review

Morrison opens up strong with an inaugural issue that sets up a very different, more bizarre version of space than we've seen in previous runs. If you're looking for a book that picks up where the previous GL books left off, your miles may vary. Other than that, it's a mostly solid start. Read Full Review

Is The Green Lantern #1 the game-changer we were promised? Not quite. Yet it is a solid introduction to the concept of The Green Lantern Corps and it has some of the best art you'll see in a comic book this year and that is no bad thing. Read Full Review

Not surprisingly, the first issue of this hotly anticipated Grant Morrison comic reads exactly like a Grant Morrison comic. It feels a little stiff and impenetrable at first, but overall it's a solid start to a hopefully refreshing Green Lantern series. Read Full Review

The Green Lantern is, unsurprisingly, pretty damn cool. We still haven't gotten to the actual story of it, but the setup is all interesting, everything is weird and trippy and the art is spectacular. You've probably bought it already, but if you haven't, know that this is a fun book that promises an intergalactic adventure like nothing you've seen in the last few years. Buy this book. Read Full Review

The Green Lantern #1 is an exciting new direction from acclaimed writer Grant Morrison. Read Full Review

If you're looking for a character-driven story that aims to hit you in the gut, The Green Lantern #1 probably isn't it. But if you're looking for a creatively fertile intergalactic epic that excites the part of your brain that dares to endlessly imagine, then welcome to the party. Read Full Review

If nothing else, the satirical sense of humor alone is worth the price of admission, however these moments play into the expanding new Green Lantern series. Read Full Review

It's what modern superhero comics needs. Purity. An utter lack of pretension. Battles between what's right and wrong produced plain as brightest day. There's aDoomsday Clock reference in this issue. Ignore it. The big-time stuff in The Green Lantern, both in this issue and the ones yet to come, will be found in the nitty-gritty of cosmic DC, where heroes dare and villains beware. Read Full Review

Overall: The Green Lantern #1 was an excellent read. Morrison delivers an issue that is wonderfully complex and dense with so many intricate plot lines. There is something for nearly any type of reader on this title. Readers who prefer complex reads will enjoy this issue just as much as readers who prefect action and adventure. The Green Lantern #1 absolutely offers a ton of content for your money. I have a good feeling that The Green Lantern is going to be a special DC comic book. Read Full Review

A much needed reintroduction to the trappings of the Green Lantern Corps is welcome, if not altogether thrilling. We see space cops in action, and Hal Jordan whipping up constructs. It's too early to get overly jazzed for this series, but all signs look positive. Read Full Review

This book is meant to be the next big Lantern book. At this stage, I am not sue if there was a need. With the final story of Green Lanterns and inclusion of the Corps, it feels that DC kind of got bored with Simon and Jessica, which is a shame as at least these two had differences far from the hero stereotype. This book is difficult to score as Morrison writes for the long game, meaning that down the line, this book may turn into something fantastic. However, as it stands, this issue gives me so much that I have seen before at the expense of a Lantern book that was trying to be so different. Read Full Review

I wanted this book to be good and to entertain me but other than the art it falls flat. Hopefully it gets better with the second issue but for now I won't hold my breath. Read Full Review

This issue is a bit of a mixed bag. While there's certainly a lot of interesting new Lanterns introduced and a serious threat at hand, the characterization of Hal is a little contrived. At the end of Robert Venditti's run on Hal Jordan and the Green Lantern Corps, Hal and Carol seemed like they had come to an important moment in their relationship that would be ripe for exploration. Venditti's run was so strong on character, moving away from that moment without a mention is a bit jarring. Hal's characterization has reverted back to an iconic, yet unenlightened portrayal. This issue is probably more enjoyable read cold without the knowledge of what's come just before in Hal Jordan and the Green Lantern Corps. Read Full Review

Onething Ive noticed with the Green Lantern franchise the past year or two is howmuch of it is space-based. Hal and the rest of the Corps serve as intergalacticcops, but almost never (in recent memory) has he or the others playedsuper-hero on Earth. I kind of miss that. Cosmic adventures are all fun andambitious, but once in a while I enjoy a simpler tale, as a palette cleanser.But event fatigue is a common problem from DC the past decade or so. Everythinghas to be BIG. Read Full Review

These aren't the visuals I want to see on a Lantern book, so I'm one and done with this series. This is a shame because I love the Corps and I've loved Morrison's past works, but I can't get beyond the art. This is a title I would rather read than view. Catch you later, Hal. Read Full Review

This is a very interesting start. Morrison and Sharpe make an excellent team and I'll be reading further issues as they come out. I certainly hadn't realised though quite how many different Corps there now seems to be! Seems there a lot more than the visible rainbow spectrum now! Read Full Review

Samuel Almeida

Nov 07, 2018

Holy damn did i felt good reading this! Its better than what i was hoping for! I love Grant Morrison so much hes my favorite writer! But i think the artist deserves even more praise. Liam Sharp draws like a god creating the universe. Hes in another level! I have sincere love and admiration for his work on The Brave And The Bold and im glad hes drawing one of my favorite characters. If he doesnt get nominated for AT LEAST ONE Eisner Award next year i swear to god i will flip out! Anyways... I loved this book. Some people wont feel the same but i just really think its THAT good.

mynameisraj

Nov 08, 2018

Absolutely the most satisfying #1 I have read in ages. Morrison and Sharp take GL away from typical superhero fare and place it closer to British sci-fi stuff. It's got far more in common with 2000 AD and Valerian than any other DC book out right now.

Synthozoid

Nov 10, 2018

Classic Morrison. His best work since All Star Superman. Similar in tone to Slott’s Silver Surfer, but much weirder.

Kitsilog

Nov 10, 2018

LOVE! IT!

Br'er Lapin AKA 20-Ish Ceiln

Nov 10, 2018

Grant Morrison shows he is well versed in Silver Age Green Lantern and as a fan who has been hoping for a return to that style, I am very pleased with this. Liam Sharp's art really surprised me, it perfectly fit Morrison's story.

RyanSmith28

Nov 07, 2018

Morrison writes a really great space cop series with a lot of promising stuff to come and Liam Sharp’s art perfectly fits the weird but fun tone.

Psycamorean

Nov 10, 2018

Really strong first issue. The stuff without Hal reminded me a lot of Dan Slott's Silver Surfer, which I'm overall a big fan of. The stuff with Hal was also really good. I actually didn't find Hal obnoxious in his ego this time, unlike in Hal Jordan and the Green Lantern Corps, as well as the last Green Lanterns arc. I'm not sure what the ending was about though. One thing that doesn't really bother me, but it's worth noting, this ignores the end of Hal Jordan. At least in regards to Hal's love life. I don't really care because that felt shoehorned into that last issue anyway, but it makes the decision even weirder given that it was not picked up by Morrison.

MKW69

Nov 07, 2018

Finally a good DC book! Beginning vas very good, like straight from 2000 AD. My only problem is the middle when Hal isn't a Green Lantern. He hooked up with Carol in Venditti Run. Who is this girl?

+ Like • Comments (1)

• Likes (1)

• ohhaimark

Br'er Lapin AKA 20-Ish Ceiln - Nov 10, 2018

She is one of Hal's very brief love interests that he met in 60s' GL as he was an insurance salesman.

myconius

Nov 07, 2018

Grant Morrison comics always read better upon re-reads, you’ll definitely get your money’s worth! if you’re a fan of his writing you are in for a real treat. if you’re not a fan, best stay away. there’s a lot to keep up with. and you’d better read it slow and carefully. Grant’s stories always hit the ground running. any info you need to know, you find out along the way. one of the things i love about Grant’s writing is there is SO much going on in just one issue. he really knows how to tell as vast story and move a plot. NO DECOMPRESSION HERE! so creative and imaginative! this comic is just bursting with concepts and ideas. plenty of action as well! ((((spoilers ahead)))) we’re introduced to som e Green Lanterns trying to take down some Space Pirates. they are up against some pretty formidable odds, but end up victorious. …or so it would seem. enter Hal Jordon. he seems to be down on his luck. lost his job on Earth. fired from the Green Lanterns. well, not all of Hal’s luck is bad. He spends his evening with the company of a beautiful Lady. the next morning as he goes about his way he is confronted by a derelict. the derelict is talking non-comprehensible. Hal immediately concludes the man is actually a space alien. a Colony Creature. being good at what he does, Hal defeats the alien. shortly after Hal finds one the Lanterns, Chriselon that was trying to bring in the space pirates. he is hurt really bad. Hal wants to help, but explains that while he still has his Green Lantern ring the Guardians took away his power battery. Chriselon gives Hal his power battery. Hal powers up and goes after the escaped Space fugitives. so much more happens, but i don’t want to spoil anymore than i already have. ((((end spoilers)))) if you are a fan of Grant Morrison, you will definitely want to check this out. even if you are not a Morrison fan, but are a fan of Green Lantern this may still be worth your time. just read carefully, and pay attention to the many details and ideas presented. once again…. Grant Morrison comics always read better upon re-reads, so try to keep that in mind, and you will definitely get your money’s worth! my only wish is that someone like Frank Quitely would have drawn this first issue and opening arc. Liam Sharp's are is really good, but it just doesn't get the feel of depth or perspective that an artist like Quitely does. that being said, Liam Sharp's faces he draws are quite excellent. his Hal Jordan really has that classic Bronze age look that i really enjoy. more

+ Like • Comments (10)

• Likes (4)

• Haand
• Br'er Lapin AKA 20-Ish Ceiln
• ohhaimark
• Linkush

Show all comments

ohhaimark - Nov 7, 2018

Glad to see this lived up to the expectations! Grant Morrison is one of my favorite writers, Doom Patrol and Animal Man easily both crack my top five favorite comics. This review gets me excited!

myconius - Nov 7, 2018

you should be in for a real treat then, and i feel you'll be right at home with this comic! 😃 . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . also, after reading this issue over again, i had to raise my initial score up a mark. you're definitely going get your money's worth here. 🙃

ohhaimark - Nov 7, 2018

Awesome!

Comix4fever - Nov 7, 2018

Have either of you read Klaus?

myconius - Nov 7, 2018

i really loved the Klaus mini-series. the two one-shots that were released later on were also good.

ohhaimark - Nov 8, 2018

Yes, I have. I also really enjoyed it.

myconius - Nov 10, 2018

my only wish is that Frank Quitely would have drawn this first issue, as well as the entire first arc.

ohhaimark - Nov 10, 2018

That would be awesome! Frank Quitely is a great artist! I still love Liam Sharp's art, but I think that Quitely's art certainly works better with the writing.

myconius - Nov 10, 2018

i definitely enjoy Liam Sharp's art in this. i'm just coveting the idea of what could have been. at least we had gotten Grant and Quitely's JLA: Earth 2 a few years ago. that was amazing to see Frank Quitely drawing Kyle Rayner constructing those two giant hands clasping over the Crime Syndicate's Moon Base. SO awesome!! . . . . but Sharp is pretty good. my favorite work he did is the Death Dealer comics he did for Verotik. pretty sure i still have those in my collection . . . . somewhere. :-P

ohhaimark - Nov 10, 2018

I LOVED EARTH 2! I'll have to check those other Liam Sharp comics out!

Kurogane

Nov 07, 2018

As someone who hasn't read GL since Johns' run, this was pretty much perfect for me. Hal's character is distilled down to it's very basics, a fearless and free spirit. Added to that is Morrison's crazy stuff as usual, except this time it all fits really well. Overall I'm excited to see that this will be a serious story at it's core but I hope the fun continues. And damn man, Liam Sharp, he's awesome

Jeremy Cline

Nov 08, 2018

[[DISCLAIMER: THE WRITER OF THIS REVIEW ACKNOWLEDGES THAT 100 PERCENT OF COMIC BOOK ARTISTS DRAW BETTER THAN HE EVER COULD & THAT MOST COMIC BOOK WRITERS WRITE BETTER (COMIC BOOKS) THAN HE EVER COULD...so with that out of the way...]] Approach this book in the following way: as if you have never heard of Green Lantern and you are reading a story about him and his kind for the first time. Just let it sweep you along.

Full Spread

Nov 08, 2018

I've always liked the concept of Green Lantern. But every comic I read was so painfully self-serious and unimaginative. Well...those are some things you never have to worry about with Grant Morrison. One of my favorite issues of the year.

ohhaimark

Nov 09, 2018

THE GOOD: -This issue gets credit just for feeling like a modern classic. Seriously, I bet that when this run's over, assuming all the other issues are consistent with this one, it will not only have a huge following, it will go down in history as one of, if not the greatest Green Lantern run of all time. -That art was amazing. I've never really read anything illustrated by Liam Sharp before, but this issue really makes me want to. Truly amazing. -I think Floozle Flem is the new best member of the Green Lantern Corps. All joking aside, I am trying to make a point here, and it's that there is some excellent originality in this issue. Also, I know it's only mentioned, but I am totally excited by idea of a microwave green lantern. -This series is genuinely a step above all the other DC series I'm reading right now. It is unique, and it feels like something refreshingly new for a publisher that a few weeks ago, I was concerned about running out of fuel. -BUMS RULE! -Overall, I'm just excited by the setup in this issue. Not only do the coming soon pages excite me, they make me sit on the edge of my seat for what's to come. Also, I'm just really interested because of the mystery and that final page. -Grant Morrison is a great writer. This issue oozes with genius and master writing. THE BAD: -The only complaint I can come up with is a small one, and its that the character of Green Lantern could improve. I'm not saying it's bad, but it's the only aspect of this issue that feels like it could be better in some way. He is a clever, cool character who has sex outside his house, but I haven't really been given too many reasons to connect with him. more

Spacey Medicine

Jun 02, 2019

This was really good!

M1sf1r3

Jan 24, 2020

Prelude: It's time for Morrison's The Green Lantern. Let's see how this goes. The Good: I like how confident Hal is. He's saved the universe so many times, it makes sense he's on top of it all by now. Some cool Silver Age elements here from the GL's to the ending with Controller Mu. Didn't expect that Doctor Manhattan reference. Liam Sharp's art perfectly fits the story. The coming soon page looks promising. The Bad: I don't like how Morrison ditched the ending of Hals n Pals immediately. Conclusion: Look, it's a great start in of itself but regarding the recent events of Hals n Pals, it does weaken the issue a bit.

Another Nerd

Feb 14, 2020

Thanks DC for cutting this ‘season’ down to 8 issues... This series is one of the few good things you’re putting out right now. 5G better be worth it. 😕

losdutchmen

Nov 08, 2018

I've never read a Green Lantern book. I picked this up out of curiosity, and because Morrison was the writer. It was like jumping off the high dive for the first time; a huge splash, then some disorientation while I figured out which way was up. The art grabbed my attention at the beginning, the style is definitely a throwback and gave me a lot to look at. Then I started getting the hang of the "flow" of the writing and it got interesting by the end. My only question is, is GL a serious book, or does it have a tongue in cheek sense of humor. Either way, I'll grab #2 and see how this plays out.

I Review Comics

Nov 10, 2018

To be perfectly honest I've never been a Green Lantern fan. It's not that I dislike the character, more so that I could never find a point during the characters run that was suitable to jump in. That changed this week when I picked up Grant Morrison and  Liam Sharp's Green Lantern #1. This comic is fantastic and although I'm still somewhat confused by some of the lore and how the Green Lantern Corps operate, it's a great jumping on point for the series and character of Hal Jordan. He's an experienced space cop with a power ring, nuff said.   The story leads with what appears to be a routine Lantern mission in space. Some criminals are captured and while being transported the ship crashes on earth. Hal Jordan happens upon them and manages to kick their asses without falling back on his powers. In this sequence, We're quickly given a rundown of core qualities of Hal's character. He's an experienced pilot, he's a fighter and fearless. Once he's back in action as a Green Lantern he's shown to be simple yet efficient with his ring. He doesn't use more energy than is necessary to get a Job done. By the end of the issue, Hal is back into his familiar role as Earth protector as a looming threat approaches. ​ The story here in this issue is simple yet dense with content.  It's full of weird and unique characters as well as interesting landscapes and locales. Liam gets a lot to work with and rises to the occasion, nothing is ever boring.  ​​ My only complaints are that in some spots there seems to be too much going on. It's nothing major but as a noob to the GL in general It was somewhat overwhelming in a single issue. The other gripe is that the paper quality of the the comic seems to have taken a step backward. It doesn't hurt the comics overall but the colors supplied by Steve Oliff don't  pop as much as you would expect considering the scale that that the issue attempts to convey.    It will be interesting to see what the team comes up with going forward.  The scope is a lot grander than what I'm used to seeing in my usual DC comics. I can't say I'll be sticking with the series long term but the first issue has piqued my interest in the character and to see where the story goes. more

TheAdventurer

Nov 14, 2018

Grant Morrison and Liam Sharp do what they do best and get WEIRD. Additionally Shout out to Tom Orzechowski's lettering, which is some of the best I've seen in a mainstream super-hero book in a while.

mrDovydas

Mar 13, 2019

They don't make books like this these days. Very 2000AD-ish feeling, some of the best artwork that could be found in big two's books these days, and that classic Morrison writing. Yes please.

egonnn244

Nov 09, 2018

"Beware my power" Grant Morrison's work is mostly a hit or miss for me. But this book seems promising. It has this innate weirdness that I associate with his work, but the story bits laid here are interesting and his portrayal of the first human lantern is spot on. Jordan is super confident, borderline on arrogant, and doesn't take it from anyone. And, as it should be, he is a very skilled ring-slinger, easily handling three dangerous space-criminals. As for Liam Sharp, he is great. His art is very detailed and just fills up every single panel. There is also something really old school about his art. I don't know exactly what it is, but I'm pretty sure not many today's modern artists draw this way.

Simon DelMonte

Nov 08, 2018

If this were a new series with new characters continuing the legacy of the Green Lanterns, I would like this a lot more. It has a welcome and delightful 2000 AD vibe to it. But it utterly ignores everything that's been done in the GL books since, I don't know, 1984? No other humans GLs, almost no familiar GLs at all, an even more underdeveloped Hal than usual, and all the work that's been done with the Corps by Johns and Vendetti forgotten. I get that Grant does what he wants, but that doesn't have to come at the cost of losing what everyone else did.

SloboSOY

Nov 09, 2018

Hey once more Hal Jordan is a jerk I don't like at all ... Yeah ! So in one hand I really love the starting point. Not starting with Hal is brillant and I really like lantern 2018.2 and his partner Flooze Flem. IF 2018.2 is dead I hope that not the case for Flooze. I start to see once again Spider-Pirates, with a fine team (love the size-shifter). I think both Chriselion & her partner is form the same sector but not shure. In the other hand I don't like Hal in this state of mind ... wandering like if he don't have anything to hang on. Until he beat the creep of the alien (Not my favorite part) and accept to borrow Chryselion lantern (Not is brightest moment even if this is for saving live, I was more in front of a addict). I really like the gardians explaining the role they have (Even if we know that I could see some variation). But I'm really not a fan of the ending ! Cover - The regular, nice but a little static. Not giving a thing about what inside. 1/2 Writing - There is good and bad stuff. I wonder if the sexe scene & the gore one are really needed. 2.5/3 Arts - Very Nice, maybe too nice because the end is too violent with this realistic style. I want to read DC comics not Avatar one. 2.5/3 Feeling - Not hooked, even more repulsed by the ending. Mixed, will see if I take issue two or not 1/2 more

Gizmo

Nov 29, 2018

A decent start, but I must say that I'm not getting the hype: where is the complexity in this plot? I think it's relatively average so far. I'm interested with where we are picking up with Hal, though his line about fighting is more characteristic of Guy Gardner; we're getting a bit of a hybrid between Hal and Guy here. The figure drawing is wonky in a couple panels and the clothing often looks overly wrinkled, but the layouts and inking are interesting, so I like the artwork overall. The end has me interested on what will happen next.

waltgator93

Nov 06, 2018

Story started out eh but by the end it was just ok. Because this is a number one issue, really wish it would give the reader some information on Hal Jordan. Especially from where he left off with him. Although I was not as lost as I was in the beginning of the issue. So the first Lantern we saw, his finger can still fly without it being attached to him? Unfortunately even wasn’t a fan of the artwork. Feel like everything is out of order

Talon1load

Nov 07, 2018

This was a typical Morrison comic. A lot of nonsense that lets you know he probably writes everything while high. The story and art were just kind of meh. If you’re not a Morrison fan then this book isn’t going to change your views.

BirdmanG07

Aug 21, 2019

I tried to care, I couldn’t. Didn’t enjoy Morrison’s take or how everything that happened in the previous book was completely thrown out the window, but hey, that’s comics.

ShabaTG

Nov 07, 2018

I went in wanting to like this one. I kept looking for moments, but there were few I liked. Overall it was an uninteresting story, with muddled dialog, and was completely void of any emotional content or connection to any character. The art was good, but too detailed in places (especially the smaller panels) which distracted me from what was happening.

+ Like • Comments (6)

• Likes (3)

• Talon1load
• bleep_blorp_bloop
• JBL Reviews

Show all comments

Samuel Almeida - Nov 9, 2018

In my 23 years of life that must be the first time i see "detailed art" as a bad thing. wow

Talon1load - Nov 10, 2018

The art wasn’t great. There were a few good panels but overall it was just us engaging.

myconius - Nov 15, 2018

i think i might understand what ShabaTG means by the art being "too detailed in places" . . . . meaning that if there's too much detail in the background it'll take away from the focal point. (i.e. - where the viewer’s eye should be drawn to) ... the colorist could have muted the background color a bit and left the main figures vibrant. this would have made the main figures more prominent and stand out more within the panels.

ohhaimark - Nov 15, 2018

That would have improved the art. I still loved the art because of how much effort was put into it, and for me personally it really brought the book to life and made it unique, which suited the writing really well. Just my opinion though...

myconius - Nov 15, 2018

i didn't mind Liam Sharp's art at all. i really liked the facial features he drew for Hal. ...but the coloring (especially in the backgrounds) definitely could have used some depth and atmosphere.

ohhaimark - Nov 15, 2018

I do think the coloring detracted from the book, for sure. It didn’t really bother me personally though.