Chris Y's Profile

Joined: Nov 25, 2024

Recent Activity

Chris Y commented on this:
Lock reviewed Amazing X-Men #2 Nov 5, 2025
9.5

Finally a good MacKay X-men book?

Amazing X-Men #2

By: Jed MacKay, Mahmud Asrar
Released: Nov 5, 2025

OUT OF THE FRYING PAN AND INTO THE HELLFIRE! X YEARS LATER, the X-Men find themselves at the mercy of the Darkchild and her demon knight, the Juggernaut! Can the X-Men escape Providence, or will they join the residents of that cursed city in damnation? A new ally joins them, but new truths coming to light threaten to tear them apart!

+ LikeComments (1)
Chris Y - Nov 5, 2025

Don't get your hopes up, it's only gonna be three issues. ;)

Chris Y reviewed Hyde Street #9 Sep 24, 2025
9.0

Another masterfully written story. It's hard to criticize Francis Portela's art, as it is absolutely perfect, but I think it might be a little too pretty and clean for Hyde Street. I can't help but wonder what the issue would have looked like illustrated by regular artist Ivan Reis.

Hyde Street #9

By: Geoff Johns, Francis Portela
Released: Sep 24, 2025

Doctor Victor Frankenstein has nothing on Hyde Street’s own Doctor Archibald Ego—a disgraced plastic surgeon whose malpractice scars more than flesh...it cuts into the soul. Dragged to Hyde Street in 1997, Doctor Ego now encounters an old patient lured back by unfinished business—and a thirst for revenge. But when the scalpel turns, who becom...

+ LikeComments (3)
Chris Y - Nov 5, 2025 (edited)

I can see your point. It's a matter of personal taste. I wasn't an initial fan of Reis's either, but his artwork grew on me pretty fast. I don't see too much similarity to Adams - but even if there was, why shouldn't it work? Very few artists reinvent the wheel completely.

George - Nov 6, 2025

For me Reis is an excellent artist with a classic style. I think this title needs someone that can do creepy. Best comparison I can think of is Romita versus Ditko.

Chris Y reviewed Planet She-Hulk #1 Nov 5, 2025
7.0

I’d rather have Jen back on Earth, but Planet She-Hulk is obviously a concept we all needed - or so Marvel thinks. The result is an issue that feels like a 1970s fantasy comic, and that’s not a bad thing. Aaron Kuder’s art has its moments, although his facial anatomy could use some improvement. The story is not too exciting, but compelling enough to keep me interested. All in all, Planet Sh more

Planet She-Hulk #1

By: Stephanie Phillips, Aaron Kuder
Released: Nov 5, 2025

SAKAAR, PARTY OF ONE! SHE-HULK is back, and she's... stuck on Sakaar?? Spinning out of Jonathan Hickman's hit cosmic epic, IMPERIAL, Jennifer Walters made a promise to her cousin, HULK, to watch over the planet Sakaar and its people for a few days. But it's been longer than a few days, and now She-Hulk is in charge of keeping the peace on a planet ...

+ LikeComment
Chris Y reviewed Longshots #2 Nov 5, 2025
1.0

You had one job, Marvel: put an artist on this book that knows how to draw children.

Longshots #2

By: Gerry Duggan, Alan Robinson
Released: Nov 5, 2025

HOW I LEARNED TO STOP WORRYING AND LOVE MOJO! X YEARS LATER, the stage is set for a show unlike any other! One so violent, so vile, we have to put the X-BABIES on the cover otherwise we'd have to be a polybagged RED BAND BOOK! Watch as your favorite characters get plucked from existence and destroyed - all for YOUR entertainment! You can't miss out...

+ LikeComment
Chris Y reviewed Binary #2 Nov 5, 2025
2.0

The story is bullshit and the art is girlie crap.

Binary #2

By: Stephanie Phillips, Giada Belviso
Released: Nov 5, 2025

THE MIGHT OF THE PHOENIX! X YEARS LATER, BINARY faces threats from all angles - REVELATION's treacherous world, with its endlessly encroaching dangers. The people she's trying desperately to keep safe, whose resentment for her protection has reached a boiling point. And now…a face from the past, determined to bring chaos and destruction that will...

+ LikeComment
Chris Y reviewed Laura Kinney: Sabretooth #2 Nov 5, 2025
1.0

I’d respect this if it were fan art, but it isn’t.

Laura Kinney: Sabretooth #2

By: Erica Schultz, Valentina Pinti
Released: Nov 5, 2025

SABRETOOTH HUNTS HER FAMILY! X YEARS LATER, SABRETOOTH must hunt her sister GABBY and half brother AKIHIRO as they flee the REVELATION TERRITORIES! But who travels with them, and what threat do they hold over the fate of Revelation? PLUS: The return of a landmark X-VILLAIN!

+ LikeComment
Chris Y reviewed Amazing X-Men #2 Nov 5, 2025
8.0

I’m shocked. This is probably the first time Jed McKay’s writing actually works. He definitely made his homework regarding Scott and Illyana’s histories and it all comes together seamlessly. I also liked the weird little details, such as the workers producing suffering as sustenance for Limbo or Animalia changing into different animal forms. Mahmud Asrar makes it all look great too. So, as m more

Amazing X-Men #2

By: Jed MacKay, Mahmud Asrar
Released: Nov 5, 2025

OUT OF THE FRYING PAN AND INTO THE HELLFIRE! X YEARS LATER, the X-Men find themselves at the mercy of the Darkchild and her demon knight, the Juggernaut! Can the X-Men escape Providence, or will they join the residents of that cursed city in damnation? A new ally joins them, but new truths coming to light threaten to tear them apart!

+ LikeComment
Chris Y reviewed Amazing Spider-Man #15 Nov 5, 2025
4.0

The absence of Pepe Larraz makes it all too obvious that Kelly’s story is just not that interesting. This “succulent” Spider-Man sucks.

Amazing Spider-Man #15

By: Joe Kelly, Pepe Larraz
Released: Nov 5, 2025

THE SECRETS OF SPACE REVEALED! Spider-Man takes on a challenge of single combat to save his new crew and finds himself between a rock and a GIANT ALIEN BEAST INTENT ON HIS DEATH! Not only does Spider-Man learn aspects of his quest that he didn't expect, but his companions learn things about Spider-Man that THEY didn't expect. Witness the first full...

+ LikeComment
Chris Y reviewed G.I. Joe #13 Nov 5, 2025
8.0

Tom Reilly is back, which means I have no complaints with the art. A lot is happening in this issue, and while I appreciate more content in times of decompressed storytelling, it feels that things are moving a little too fast. I think it would have benefitted the story if Williamson had given the reader some more time to digest the surprising twists and turns of this first part of Dreadnok War.

G.I. Joe #13

By: Joshua Williamson, Tom Reilly
Released: Nov 5, 2025

NEW ARC

THE DREADNOK WAR BEGINS HERE!

When Cobra Commander is betrayed by one of his closest allies, he’s targeted for revenge by the Dreadnoks!

But in his darkest hour, the only one who can save Cobra Commander is…Duke?

The team-up you never expected kicks off THE BIGGEST G.I...

+ LikeComment
Chris Y added Goran Parlov to their creator watch list Nov 4, 2025
+ LikeComment
Chris Y reviewed Expatriate X-Men #1 Oct 29, 2025
6.0

This wasn’t as bad as I expected. Yes, I don’t care about these characters, since most of them haven’t been X-Men longer than five minutes and the rest is being introduced in this very issue - but I also felt myself drawn into the story, the art is actually not bad and in contrast to NYX and Extraordinary X-Men, there is no woke nonsense here (so far). On the other hand: who cares about thi more

Expatriate X-Men #1

By: Eve Ewing, Francesco Mortarino
Released: Oct 29, 2025

UNITED BY WAR! X YEARS LATER, like the fallen and reassembled United States, the new team of MS. MARVEL, BRONZE, MELEE and RIFT rises! They have seized control of the Mississippi River waters that divide mutantkind from the rest of humanity. Feared and powerful, their guerrilla tactics keep them in control - until a high-stakes mission to extract a...

+ LikeComments (2)
Hexum - Oct 31, 2025

I found out the hard way that NYX was written by somebody with hate in their heart. Thanks for the heads up about Extraordinary

Chris Y - Nov 3, 2025 (edited)

I'm not sure about hate. These people probably think they are doing good. However, they are propagating a harmful ideology through their comic book writing. Most (or even all) of them openly admit that and even brag about it on X.

Chris Y reviewed Imperial #4 Nov 2, 2025
4.0

What? This was it? I wonder if it was always planned as a four-issue series, or if they shortened it because Hickman lost interest in a project again. However, this was bullshit.

Imperial #4

By: Jonathan Hickman, Iban Coello
Released: Oct 29, 2025

Part FOUR of a four-part Marvel cosmic event! WAR!

+ LikeComment
Chris Y reviewed Batman & Robin: Year One #12 Nov 2, 2025
9.0

This last chapter felt kind of anticlimactic, but overall, Waid and Samnee created the perfect Batman comic.

Batman & Robin: Year One #12

By: Mark Waid, Chris Samnee
Released: Oct 29, 2025

The fate of Gotham hangs in the balance as Batman and Robin battle through a horde of clay monsters that have overtaken the city!

+ LikeComment
Chris Y reviewed Cloak Or Dagger #1 Oct 29, 2025
6.0

I'm a huge C&D fan, but this book is missing what has made this series special. There's some interesting melodrama and mystery around Tandy and Ty's daughter, but for the most part, this is just a faceless superhero comic with some sassy standard dialogue that didn't require much creativity on Justina Ireland's part. The art by Lorenzo Tammetta is surprisingly good compared to most Marvel art thes more

Cloak Or Dagger #1

By: Justina Ireland, Lorenzo Tammetta
Released: Oct 29, 2025

GHOSTED! X YEARS LATER, and Tandy and Tyrone have tied the knot - but their bond has come with a terrible cost. Now they can no longer exist on the same plane at the same time. Reunited at last, the fan-favorite characters from the hit Marvel Rivals face a love story warped by power and fate.

+ LikeComment
Chris Y rated Detective Comics #1102 Oct 24, 2025
9.0

Detective Comics #1102

By: Tom Taylor, Mikel Janin
Released: Oct 22, 2025

A mysterious weaponized virus has infected the Dark Knight, and he does not know how long he has left before it takes control of his body and mind. Desperate for answers and unsure how long he has to get them, Batman turns to one of the most brilliant minds in the DC Universe, Mr. Terrific. “The Courage That Kills” continues in this can’t-mis...

+ LikeComment
Chris Y rated Rook: Exodus #6 Oct 24, 2025
9.5

Rook: Exodus #6

By: Geoff Johns, Jason Fabok
Released: Oct 23, 2024

End of Story Arc. The epic conclusion of this first chapter! It's Rook versus Ursaw in a winner-takes-all gambit, as the fate of the planet Exodus-and all who inhabit it-hangs in the balance. Plus: Who is Ursaw? And what does he really want from Exodus?

+ LikeComment
Chris Y reviewed Rook: Exodus #5 Oct 24, 2025
9.0

It took me a few issues, but I’m hooked now.

Rook: Exodus #5

By: Geoff Johns, Jason Fabok
Released: Sep 4, 2024

Ursaw: Ruler of Exodus! Rook: Food for vultures? Left for dead after last issue's slobber knocker, Rook faces his greatest fears as the animal world completely turns against him! And without them, he's frankly better off dead. Also: what does Ursaw plan to do with his prize?

+ LikeComment
Chris Y reviewed Skinbreaker #2 Oct 24, 2025
9.5

I expected to see a continuation of the excellence of issue 1. What I didn't expect was another twist. I haven't the slightest idea where this epic story is heading next, and I love it.

Skinbreaker #2

By: Robert Kirkman, David Finch
Released: Oct 22, 2025

ROBERT KIRKMAN AND DAVID FINCH’S EXPLOSIVE EPIC CONTINUES!

The challenge has been made.

ROBERT KIRKMAN AND DAVID FINCH’S EXPLOSIVE EPIC CONTINUES! The challenge has been made. ROBERT KIRKMAN AND DAVID FINCH’S EXPLOSIVE EPIC CONTINUES!

The challenge has been made.

And ...

+ LikeComment
Chris Y reviewed Fantastic Four #4 Oct 24, 2025
2.0

I like the idea behind this story, but the way it is written, it just doesn't work. If the Alicia I know would find out that some unknown creature has invaded the FF`s home by posing as a harmless dog, she wouldn't wait until the existence of the alien is confirmed. She would see it as the immediate threat it is and warn the FF! I mean... if this isn't a reason to be alarmed, what is? It could be more

Fantastic Four #4

By: Ryan North, Humberto Ramos
Released: Oct 22, 2025

Alicia has returned from a sculpture convention to discover the Fantastic Four have a new pet - an adorable new dog that everyone tells her she'll love. But when she first touches the creature, it's cold, it's wet, it's slimy and it's wrong - at least until a moment later, when suddenly, she feels the warm and soft fur she's expecting. Alicia is th...

+ LikeComment
Chris Y rated Rook: Exodus #4 Oct 23, 2025
8.0

Rook: Exodus #4

By: Geoff Johns, Jason Fabok
Released: Jul 24, 2024

It's all-out war on the planet Exodus! The bear warden Ursaw wants complete control over the world, and he'll destroy anyone and anything in his path. Rook, Dire Wolf, and their newfound allies are the only remaining wardens left to stop him. The question is: What could Ursaw possibly want with a dying planet everyone else is trying to escape?

+ LikeComment
Chris Y rated Rook: Exodus #3 Oct 23, 2025
7.0

Rook: Exodus #3

By: Geoff Johns, Jason Fabok
Released: Jun 26, 2024

As Rook and Dire Wolf are hunted by the bear warden Ursaw, they need allies to fight back. Dire Wolf takes them to a secret sanctuary called the Oasis, where we meet another enigmatic Warden and his formidable crew. But can they be trusted? And whose side are they really on? Also: If you think you know how sick and twisted Ursaw is, you've seen not...

+ LikeComment
Chris Y rated Rook: Exodus #2 Oct 23, 2025
7.0

Rook: Exodus #2

By: Geoff Johns, Jason Fabok
Released: May 22, 2024

In the far future, the man known only as Rook wants out. He reckons anywhere is better than the crumbling planet Exodus, where all of nature-especially its imported animal population-has grown out of control as the world's engine has utterly failed. Scavenging for an escape vessel, he's interrupted by the power-hungry bear master named Ursaw, who w...

+ LikeComment
Chris Y commented on this:
sad comics reviewed Punisher: Red Band #2 Oct 22, 2025
1.0

What you're seeing here isn't a comic worthy of attention, but rather some woke shit whose websites (which no one cares about) rate it as a 10, when, for them, comics should be just that: stupid fun and that's it. The kind of mentality of a teenager (which we understand so far), but what makes the praise even more bizarre in the face of this shit is that they come from nerdy adults (which in itsel more

Punisher: Red Band #2

By:
Released: Oct 15, 2025

+ LikeComments (5)
sad comics - Oct 22, 2025

I really hope you're not disappointed by this any more than I.

Chris Y - Oct 22, 2025

Well, thanks. To be honest, at this point I'm used to being disappointed by Marvel eventually. So I'm enjoying it while I can.

Chris Y reviewed Rook: Exodus #1 Oct 22, 2025
7.5

Solid comic, but it doesn’t grab me just as much as the other Ghost Machine books do.

Rook: Exodus #1

By: Geoff Johns, Jason Fabok
Released: Apr 3, 2024

SERIES PREMIERE
GEOFF JOHNS and JASON FABOK, the celebrated team behind the smash hit Batman: Three Jokers, reunite for an all-new science fiction series! Hundreds of years from now, the man known as Rook was once a simple farmer who fled the crumbling Earth for a new life on the planet Exodus; a terraformed planet where all of nature, includin...

+ LikeComment
Chris Y liked this:
10

Plot
Frank Castle takes the gun from the old woman who treated him, also takes the car keys, and heads off to stop a truck with a container containing people who are about to be sent to another country for human trafficking. Kingpin gives the Punisher the coordinates.

Kingpin constantly orders Punisher what to do; his control is absolute. Kingpin self-flagellates while Frank elimin more

Punisher: Red Band #2

By:
Released: Oct 15, 2025

+ LikeComment
Chris Y reviewed Punisher: Red Band #2 Oct 22, 2025
8.5

I could do without the graphic brutality, but I love the cinematic feel of the story and artwork. I was never a huge Punisher fan, but this book is turning me into one.

Punisher: Red Band #2

By:
Released: Oct 15, 2025

+ LikeComment
Chris Y reviewed Radioactive Spider-Man #1 Oct 22, 2025
3.5

There's no reason why Radioactive Spider-Man exists as part of this crossover. Also, even if there was a halfway decent story (I'm not sure), the sucky art made it hard to follow.

Radioactive Spider-Man #1

By: Joe Kelly, Kev Walker
Released: Oct 22, 2025

UNFRIENDLY AND UNSTABLE! X YEARS LATER, the X-Virus decimated New York - but Spider-Man won't stop fighting. In a desperate gamble, Peter Parker doses himself with lethal radiation to hold the infection at bay. Survival comes at a cost. While this may not kill Peter Parker, it sure messes him up. This is the most dangerous, mutated Spider-Man ever ...

+ LikeComment
Chris Y reviewed Escape #3 Oct 22, 2025
10

I had phantom pains while reading this comic. Which, in this case, is a good thing.

Another perfect issue.

Escape #3

By: Rick Remender, Daniel Acua
Released: Oct 22, 2025

Pinned down, outgunned, and running on fumes, Milton Shaw makes a desperate push across enemy lines—with a squad of Narenian soldiers and a relentless bruiser on his heels. Trapped between a dam and a detonator, Milton’s last shot at survival is running out fast.

+ LikeComment
Chris Y liked this:
DDJamesB reviewed Escape #2 Oct 15, 2025
10

I don't give out 10s often, but this is a perfect comic. Art is great and the story makes you feel.

Escape #2

By: Rick Remender, Daniel Acua
Released: Sep 24, 2025

Wounded, hunted, and running out of time, Milton Shaw has one shot left to change the course of the war: destroy the Titan Cannon before his own side drops the bomb. But as enemy patrols close in and memories of the life he left behind threaten to break him, the mission becomes more than survival—it’s redemption.From RICK REMENDER and DANIEL AC...

+ LikeComment
1.0

This bears no resemblance to classic Dungeons & Dragons. The art is somewhat enjoyable, especially the coloring, but it’s very saccharine and serves a questionable purpose.

Dungeons & Dragons: The Fallbacks: Series 1 #1

By: Greg Pak, Wilton Santos
Released: Oct 15, 2025

In a time of fickle gods and feckless governors, the world yearns for heroes! But what it gets are the Fallbacks - a party of daring, dubious, and dysfunctional adventurers who arrive in the city of Loudwater in search of gold and glory. But an encounter with kobold thieves puts the Fallbacks in the crosshairs of a rival team of deeply annoying loc...

+ LikeComment

Reviews for the Week of...

November

October

More