This Week's Reviews
Top Comics
Trades
Publishers
Marvel
DC
Image
Dark Horse
IDW
Boom!
Dynamite
Vault
See Full List
Sign In
Andy MacDonald Comic Reviews
7.5
Critic Reviews
361
7.3
User Reviews
640
+ Creator Watch List
Current Series:
26
Total Series:
26
Issues:
61
View By:
Series
Series Rating
Issue Rating
Release Date
Critic
User
Current Comic Book Series
7.4
6.6
2020 Machine Man
2 issues
show
7.2
6.2
2020 Machine Man #1
February 19, 2020
7.5
7.1
2020 Machine Man #2
March 18, 2020
6.2
6.3
Acts of Evil: She-Hulk Annual #1
7.3
N/A
Adventures of Bio Boy #1
7.7
7.8
Batman: The Brave and the Bold (2023)
3 issues
show
7.5
7.3
Batman: The Brave and the Bold #15
July 24, 2024
7.5
8.0
Batman: The Brave and the Bold #16
August 28, 2024
8.0
8.0
Batman: The Brave and the Bold #17
September 25, 2024
7.0
7.1
Bulls of Beacon Hill
5 issues
show
6.0
6.0
Bulls of Beacon Hill #1
January 25, 2023
6.0
7.0
Bulls of Beacon Hill #2
February 22, 2023
8.0
7.0
Bulls of Beacon Hill #3
March 29, 2023
8.0
7.5
Bulls of Beacon Hill #4
April 26, 2023
N/A
8.0
Bulls of Beacon Hill #5
May 24, 2023
7.9
6.2
DC's Terrors Through Time #1
7.2
7.0
Detective Comics (2016)
2 issues
show
7.9
7.2
Detective Comics #941
September 28, 2016
6.6
6.8
Detective Comics #942
October 12, 2016
7.6
6.3
Doctor Strange Annual #1
8.4
7.3
Doctor Strange #4
7.1
5.9
Green Lantern #5
N/A
N/A
GWAR: In The Duoverse of Absurdity OGN
8.3
8.2
I Breathed a Body
5 issues
show
8.6
7.3
I Breathed a Body #1
January 20, 2021
8.0
8.4
I Breathed a Body #2
February 24, 2021
8.2
8.1
I Breathed a Body #3
March 31, 2021
7.5
9.1
I Breathed a Body #4
April 28, 2021
9.1
8.3
I Breathed a Body #5
May 26, 2021
7.0
8.6
Image! 30th Anthology
2 issues
show
6.0
8.5
Image! 30th Anthology #10
February 15, 2023
8.0
8.8
Image! 30th Anthology #11
March 15, 2023
7.0
7.4
Infinity Wars: Fallen Guardian #1
6.3
6.7
Justice League of America (2017)
5 issues
show
7.8
8.0
Justice League of America: The Atom Rebirth #1
January 4, 2017
6.1
6.4
Justice League of America #5
April 26, 2017
5.7
6.4
Justice League of America #6
May 10, 2017
5.5
6.6
Justice League of America #10
July 12, 2017
6.3
6.2
Justice League of America #11
July 26, 2017
8.8
7.8
Loki #5
6.0
N/A
Miss America 70th Anniversary Special #1
7.6
7.7
Multiple Man (2018)
5 issues
show
7.1
7.9
Multiple Man #1
June 27, 2018
7.5
7.8
Multiple Man #2
July 25, 2018
7.4
7.8
Multiple Man #3
August 15, 2018
8.2
7.6
Multiple Man #4
September 19, 2018
7.7
7.5
Multiple Man #5
October 31, 2018
8.4
8.2
My Date With Monsters
5 issues
show
7.7
6.8
My Date With Monsters #1
November 10, 2021
7.8
N/A
My Date With Monsters #2
December 15, 2021
7.3
N/A
My Date With Monsters #3
January 19, 2022
9.7
N/A
My Date With Monsters #4
February 23, 2022
9.7
9.5
My Date With Monsters #5
March 30, 2022
8.2
N/A
Punisher War Journal #26
8.5
6.8
Rogue Planet
5 issues
show
7.9
6.8
Rogue Planet #1
May 27, 2020
8.0
6.8
Rogue Planet #2
June 24, 2020
8.5
8.0
Rogue Planet #3
July 29, 2020
10
6.0
Rogue Planet #4
August 26, 2020
8.2
6.5
Rogue Planet #5
September 30, 2020
7.1
8.1
Teen Titans: Earth One #2
7.0
7.2
The Terminator: 1984 #1
6.5
7.5
The Terminator: 2029 #1
6.4
6.9
Wolverine: Infinity Watch
5 issues
show
6.8
6.9
Wolverine: Infinity Watch #1
February 20, 2019
7.5
7.5
Wolverine: Infinity Watch #2
March 20, 2019
6.8
7.1
Wolverine: Infinity Watch #3
April 17, 2019
5.4
6.8
Wolverine: Infinity Watch #4
May 22, 2019
5.6
6.3
Wolverine: Infinity Watch #5
June 19, 2019
8.1
7.6
Wonder Woman (2016)
3 issues
show
8.4
7.9
Wonder Woman Annual: 2021
December 1, 2021
8.0
7.6
Wonder Woman #774
June 23, 2021
7.9
7.4
Wonder Woman #775
July 14, 2021
All Comic Book Series
7.4
6.6
2020 Machine Man
2 issues
show
7.2
6.2
2020 Machine Man #1
February 19, 2020
7.5
7.1
2020 Machine Man #2
March 18, 2020
6.2
6.3
Acts of Evil: She-Hulk Annual #1
7.3
N/A
Adventures of Bio Boy #1
7.7
7.8
Batman: The Brave and the Bold (2023)
3 issues
show
7.5
7.3
Batman: The Brave and the Bold #15
July 24, 2024
7.5
8.0
Batman: The Brave and the Bold #16
August 28, 2024
8.0
8.0
Batman: The Brave and the Bold #17
September 25, 2024
7.0
7.1
Bulls of Beacon Hill
5 issues
show
6.0
6.0
Bulls of Beacon Hill #1
January 25, 2023
6.0
7.0
Bulls of Beacon Hill #2
February 22, 2023
8.0
7.0
Bulls of Beacon Hill #3
March 29, 2023
8.0
7.5
Bulls of Beacon Hill #4
April 26, 2023
N/A
8.0
Bulls of Beacon Hill #5
May 24, 2023
7.9
6.2
DC's Terrors Through Time #1
7.2
7.0
Detective Comics (2016)
2 issues
show
7.9
7.2
Detective Comics #941
September 28, 2016
6.6
6.8
Detective Comics #942
October 12, 2016
7.6
6.3
Doctor Strange Annual #1
8.4
7.3
Doctor Strange #4
7.1
5.9
Green Lantern #5
N/A
N/A
GWAR: In The Duoverse of Absurdity OGN
8.3
8.2
I Breathed a Body
5 issues
show
8.6
7.3
I Breathed a Body #1
January 20, 2021
8.0
8.4
I Breathed a Body #2
February 24, 2021
8.2
8.1
I Breathed a Body #3
March 31, 2021
7.5
9.1
I Breathed a Body #4
April 28, 2021
9.1
8.3
I Breathed a Body #5
May 26, 2021
7.0
8.6
Image! 30th Anthology
2 issues
show
6.0
8.5
Image! 30th Anthology #10
February 15, 2023
8.0
8.8
Image! 30th Anthology #11
March 15, 2023
7.0
7.4
Infinity Wars: Fallen Guardian #1
6.3
6.7
Justice League of America (2017)
5 issues
show
7.8
8.0
Justice League of America: The Atom Rebirth #1
January 4, 2017
6.1
6.4
Justice League of America #5
April 26, 2017
5.7
6.4
Justice League of America #6
May 10, 2017
5.5
6.6
Justice League of America #10
July 12, 2017
6.3
6.2
Justice League of America #11
July 26, 2017
8.8
7.8
Loki #5
6.0
N/A
Miss America 70th Anniversary Special #1
7.6
7.7
Multiple Man (2018)
5 issues
show
7.1
7.9
Multiple Man #1
June 27, 2018
7.5
7.8
Multiple Man #2
July 25, 2018
7.4
7.8
Multiple Man #3
August 15, 2018
8.2
7.6
Multiple Man #4
September 19, 2018
7.7
7.5
Multiple Man #5
October 31, 2018
8.4
8.2
My Date With Monsters
5 issues
show
7.7
6.8
My Date With Monsters #1
November 10, 2021
7.8
N/A
My Date With Monsters #2
December 15, 2021
7.3
N/A
My Date With Monsters #3
January 19, 2022
9.7
N/A
My Date With Monsters #4
February 23, 2022
9.7
9.5
My Date With Monsters #5
March 30, 2022
8.2
N/A
Punisher War Journal #26
8.5
6.8
Rogue Planet
5 issues
show
7.9
6.8
Rogue Planet #1
May 27, 2020
8.0
6.8
Rogue Planet #2
June 24, 2020
8.5
8.0
Rogue Planet #3
July 29, 2020
10
6.0
Rogue Planet #4
August 26, 2020
8.2
6.5
Rogue Planet #5
September 30, 2020
7.1
8.1
Teen Titans: Earth One #2
7.0
7.2
The Terminator: 1984 #1
6.5
7.5
The Terminator: 2029 #1
6.4
6.9
Wolverine: Infinity Watch
5 issues
show
6.8
6.9
Wolverine: Infinity Watch #1
February 20, 2019
7.5
7.5
Wolverine: Infinity Watch #2
March 20, 2019
6.8
7.1
Wolverine: Infinity Watch #3
April 17, 2019
5.4
6.8
Wolverine: Infinity Watch #4
May 22, 2019
5.6
6.3
Wolverine: Infinity Watch #5
June 19, 2019
8.1
7.6
Wonder Woman (2016)
3 issues
show
8.4
7.9
Wonder Woman Annual: 2021
December 1, 2021
8.0
7.6
Wonder Woman #774
June 23, 2021
7.9
7.4
Wonder Woman #775
July 14, 2021
2025 In Review:
Top Comic Series
Top Comic Issues
Top New Series
Reviews for the Week of...
February
11
4
January
28
21
14
