Yeah, I mostly feel that this hasn’t really made its mind up about what it wants a to be. It just feels that Duggan has taken a bit of a scatter-shot approach and needs tighter editing. On a side note, Marvel editors really need to start picking up the ball, there are some basic faults constantly overlooked in favour of flash, bang, wallop, and sensational storylines that are emotionally vacuous.
UW's Profile
Joined: July 23, 2019
Recent Activity
I'm a bit sorry to see this go. It wasn't groundbreaking but it was fun, and used its main cast well. It was definitely better than the lacklustre Spider-Woman arc that introduced the team.
It leaves a bouncy little void in my pick-up list.
New Champions #8
THE NEW CHAMPIONS RAISE HELA! The New Champions' search for Hellrune leads them to the land of the dead - where Hellrune's aunt readies her to wake Hela, the goddess of DEATH. With mystical forces stacked up against them and Hellrune's life on the line, the risks have never been higher for this teen team! Can they withstand one last battle against ...
I'm giving a somewhat generous mark because what this series got right was at least having an ambitious story. It never quite gelled which was a shame but the potential was there, and there were some real highlights along the way. Sadly, most of what failed was the attempts at humour that never seemed to fit or find their right moment.
Still it was nice to see Spider-Woman taken seriou
more
West Coast Avengers #10
THE MARK OF ULTRON! OMEGA ULTRON and his followers take on the West Coast Avengers for a final showdown! But as the West Coast Ultron's life hangs in the balance, can the team pull together to save him? And what will it cost Tony Stark if they succeed?
It's fun and has some nice quirky touches. Something about the ending was insatiably corny though. Still interested to see how the arc develops.
New Champions #2
NEW ALLIES...AND ENEMIES?
Hellrune has summoned young heroes from far and wide, but who among them has what it takes to become a New Champion? The smooth-talking magician Monte seems to be a prime candidate, but is he more than he appears? And who is the mysterious MAGNETRIX?
Rated T
Bit of a drop from last week, mostly because the art falters. It's inconsistent.
This issue is less about action and more about bonding and intent, and it provides more emotional content and a satisfying connection between Blue Bolt and Firestar, it just doesn't really move things forward in any way, and the stakes are no higher than they were at the end of the last issue.
more
West Coast Avengers #4
SPARKS FLY!
A troubled Firestar and the newest and least-tested member of the West Coast Avengers, Blue Bolt, make an unexpected connection - but will this volatile romance strengthen the team or burn it down?
Rated T+
This was my favourite issue so far.
It did the nice retro art thing I liked from the first issue. It gave a plausible explanation and interesting dynamic to the multiple Ultrons. It allowed Spider-Woman to shine, again, and quite honestly I could get used to that. It dialled way back on the goofiness. It had an intriguing meeting with the Illuminati. Plus it had *that* cover.
West Coast Avengers #3
As a second Ultron appears and declares himself leader of a terrifying new religion, Iron Man and War Machine reveal at last how their Ultron became a hero!
RATED T+
I enjoyed Dark X-Men by Steve Foxe. It wasn't perfect, it maybe needed a longer arc to flesh out the individual plot lines, but it meant business.
Sadly his Spider-Woman run was awful, so I was not inclined to pick this comic up (after all these characters were introduced in that book.)
However, I'm fairly glad I gave it a chance. It's fun. It's not ground breaking but it's
more
New Champions #1
WHO ARE THE NEW CHAMPIONS? What do four kids whose lives were derailed by Hydra, Scarlet Witch's mysterious protégé, a cursed roller derby jammer and a Wakandan runaway have in common? Not much! But when Hellrune's mysterious powers activate to bring them together, they'll have to learn how to work as a team quickly - or face the wrath of the Cul...
This comic is messy. I get that the team are supposed to be bad at working together, but giving such a massive introduction to Firestar, which served no purpose, and didn't add to her flaking out, seemed a misjudgment when the Angelic Ultron was reduced to pretty much one page with risible and basic dialogue. On that point, the voices are indistinct, Spider-Woman and Blue Bolt both saying "you're more
West Coast Avengers #2
NEW MEMBER: FIRESTAR FLAMES OUT!
Firestar officially joins the West Coast Avengers! But the plan for her to mentor redeemed villains like Ultron and newcomer Blue Bolt collapses when it becomes clear she's seeking redemption of her own. Her time undercover with ORCHIS left scars and made her a pariah. Can the West Coast Avengers stop her downwa...
I wish Duggan would stop trying to be funny. It just comes off awkward. Now Firestar is an alcoholic? I'm not sure why he's trying to make a new Thunderbolts team out of this. Is it a surprise to anyone that Ultron is still evil? This could be a good title if they drop the criminal side of things and just make it a team. I do miss Tigra not being a part of the team, but bring in She-Hulk and Hawk more
West Coast Avengers #1
ULTRON RETURNS...REDEEMED?
Iron Man and War Machine have put together a new team of Avengers - one that includes villains seeking a path to redemption. Their case study? Ultron - who, against all odds, seems to be walking the straight and narrow...for now. But does the success of one guarantee the success of all? Spider-Woman and Firestar...
This was a bit messy and clunky, but the premise shows promise, and that ending elevates it.
So much time was given to Tony's backstory that the issue began with an info dump rather than a compelling narrative, and we did not get much team interaction, which is a bit of a shame in a team book.
The first five pages should have been jettisoned. The comic would then have begun
more
West Coast Avengers #1
ULTRON RETURNS...REDEEMED?
Iron Man and War Machine have put together a new team of Avengers - one that includes villains seeking a path to redemption. Their case study? Ultron - who, against all odds, seems to be walking the straight and narrow...for now. But does the success of one guarantee the success of all? Spider-Woman and Firestar...
Thank goodness it's over.
I guess it was nice to see Spider-Woman finally coming off the bench for a few scant moments in the final issue but it amounted to nothing.
There was never any sense of danger, despite the hyperbolically written teasers, and no real resolution to anything. Overall, it was pointless and toothless. If the Gang War section was slow and painfully obviou
more
Spider-Woman #10
Last issue's shocking revelations lead to a brutal fight that will push Spider-Woman and the Assembly to their limits! Hydra stole Jess' son. What can she take from them? And who among the Assembly will survive to begin a NEW life as CHAMPIONS?
Rated T+
Did you ever read ‘Secret Avengers’ by Aleš Kot? It’s great comics, and I love Jess in that.
Yea, Jed McCay would be good. Benjamin Percy could probably do a good gritty story with her. I’m pretty sure I read Secret Avengers, the whole New Avengers and Secret Invasion run is what really made me start liking the character
I must be reading a different comic to a lot of others.
Yes, it has a nice cover, the art is vibrant, and the use of Angar is creative, so there's the three stars, but...
The early scenes with Liberty were mawkish, and set Jess up, again, as being a generally useless. She's solved nothing. Even the idea to reuse Angar, and the spy stuff, belonged to Liberty. Jessica is liter
more
Spider-Woman #9
Jess learns the truth about these new champions of The Assembly and whose side they're really on. But the shocking reveals keep piling up with the return of someone we thought was dead!
Rated T+
Best SW cover ever.
Sadly, I'm not feeling this book at all.
I guess I should be glad it finally seems to be picking up the pace, but to all intents and purposes this issue, end reveal aside, repeats its predecessor. Jess encounters a villain with a grudge against Echidna, The Assembly swoop in, Jess remains suspicious. Even the jokey song themed title remains the same this
more
Spider-Woman #8
WHO ARE "THE ASSEMBLY"?
Spider-Woman finds San Francisco full of old foes, old friends and a new super-team that could still be either. After a fight with Angar the Screamer, the origin of another new New Champions character will be revealed!
Rated T+
Effectively this is a repeat of the last issue but with a less appealing guest star. The new artist is fine although some of the facial expressions seem peculiar.
Turns out Jessica is now the Patron Saint of all kids, and the way things are going I fully expect her to become a surrogate parent to the mini-me New Champions.
It seems that Marvel has decided Jessic
more
Spider-Woman #6
SAN FRANCISCO BOUND!
Brokenhearted, Jess decides to leave New York for a fresh start. But the trek across country will not be a smooth ride. A new adventure starts here! Introducing some new faces and with the potential to become New...Champions?!
Rated T+
AmericanHealthCare says it all really.
Ever since the Hopeless run Handmaidened her into having a kid Jessica has been defined by no more than three things; being a mother, being Carol Danver's bestie, and, mostly, being useless. It's like she isn't allowed to exist in her own right. Half her skills are missing and, even though her bio-electric powers get name checked in this issue, th
more
Spider-Woman #7
Following the shocking revelations about her son's fate, Spider-Woman has returned to her old stomping grounds of San Francisco...where she discovers that a brand-new group of young heroes have burst onto the scene! But why does Jess have a sinking feeling that there's more to these teens than meets the eye?
Rated T+
This title really struggles. The story and questionable action stuff would be easier to forgive if the voice worked, but Jess herself and the dialogue in a broader sense are all off. This is not working.
Spider-Woman #6
SAN FRANCISCO BOUND!
Brokenhearted, Jess decides to leave New York for a fresh start. But the trek across country will not be a smooth ride. A new adventure starts here! Introducing some new faces and with the potential to become New...Champions?!
Rated T+
This one issue was more fun, and worked better, than all the Gang War issues combined.
Finally, it felt that Jessica's voice worked, and worked well. I'll never be a fan of the decision to make the one woman saying "No!", a mother, and could care less if the next time we see Gerry he is found dead behind a dumpster, but I actually empathised with Jessica for the first time. How much o
more
Spider-Woman #5
In the fallout from the explosive citywide GANG WAR, Jessica Drew uncovered the terrible truth behind the search for her missing son. Now, when she's at her lowest, the last thing Spider-Woman wants is an unexpected team-up. But try telling that to BAILEY BRIGGS, the spectacular SPIDER-BOY!
Rated T+
A step up the last few issues!
Spider-Woman #5
In the fallout from the explosive citywide GANG WAR, Jessica Drew uncovered the terrible truth behind the search for her missing son. Now, when she's at her lowest, the last thing Spider-Woman wants is an unexpected team-up. But try telling that to BAILEY BRIGGS, the spectacular SPIDER-BOY!
Rated T+
What is happening? I've usually liked Foxe's work in the past and this run started out at least functional. This feels so weird with Madame Web just coming out. Do writers just hate Spider-Wom(e)n? There are some decent story beats happening here, but the level of bonkers stupidity is just egregious. We have to suspend disbelief for comics, but everything about this issue breaks immersion. What di more
Spider-Woman #4
GANG WAR RAGES ON!
Jessica Drew finds the answers she's been looking for, but her reunion with her son propels her into a new paradigm. But first, there's a GANG WAR to finish! And Jess won't be fighting alone. Not when her best friend is Captain Marvel!
Rated T+
I think this had the potential to be better, but I thought it was still fairly good for what it was. I am interested in the story between Jessica and Gerry, and I thought the way this ended between them, for now, was good and leaves the door open for my exploration later on.
Spider-Woman #4
GANG WAR RAGES ON!
Jessica Drew finds the answers she's been looking for, but her reunion with her son propels her into a new paradigm. But first, there's a GANG WAR to finish! And Jess won't be fighting alone. Not when her best friend is Captain Marvel!
Rated T+
Steve Foxe's initial arc for Jess has had its ups and downs. It's been good when Jess has been kicking butt, but has struggled when her entire personality is confined to her being an emotional mother. I don't like that she is reduced to a blubbering female who is only defined by her motherhood.
With Gang War wrapping up, I'm willing to give this run a few more issues to move onto bigge
more
Spider-Woman #4
GANG WAR RAGES ON!
Jessica Drew finds the answers she's been looking for, but her reunion with her son propels her into a new paradigm. But first, there's a GANG WAR to finish! And Jess won't be fighting alone. Not when her best friend is Captain Marvel!
Rated T+