Mitch Gerads Comic Reviews

8.3

Critic Reviews

1007

8.0

User Reviews

2872

+ Creator Watch List

Current Series:	15
Total Series:	14
Issues:	87

View By: Series Series Rating Issue Rating Release Date

Critic User

Current Comic Book Series

8.4

8.2

Batman (2016)

4 issues show

8.0

8.4

Batman #14
January 4, 2017

8.6

8.7

Batman #15
January 18, 2017

8.9

9.0

Batman #23
May 17, 2017

7.9

6.5

Batman #62
January 9, 2019

9.3

6.9

Batman / Catwoman: Special #1

9.2

7.6

Batman: Black & White #2

7.7

8.5

Batman: One Bad Day: The Riddler #1

7.9

7.6

Batman: The Brave and the Bold (2023)

5 issues show

8.3

7.7

Batman: The Brave and the Bold #1
May 17, 2023

8.2

7.1

Batman: The Brave and the Bold #2
June 28, 2023

6.8

6.9

Batman: The Brave and the Bold #4
August 23, 2023

8.3

8.1

Batman: The Brave and the Bold #5
September 27, 2023

8.0

Batman: The Brave and the Bold #9
January 24, 2024

6.2

5.1

Heroes In Crisis

2 issues show

6.7

5.5

Heroes In Crisis #6
February 27, 2019

5.7

4.7

Heroes In Crisis #8
April 24, 2019

7.3

5.1

Legion of Super-Heroes #9

9.2

9.1

Mister Miracle (2017)

12 issues show

9.2

9.1

Mister Miracle #1
August 9, 2017

9.2

9.0

Mister Miracle #2
September 13, 2017

8.8

9.0

Mister Miracle #3
October 11, 2017

9.1

9.4

Mister Miracle #4
November 8, 2017

9.3

9.4

Mister Miracle #5
December 13, 2017

9.1

9.0

Mister Miracle #6
January 10, 2018

9.3

9.0

Mister Miracle #7
March 14, 2018

9.1

8.9

Mister Miracle #8
April 18, 2018

9.2

9.1

Mister Miracle #9
June 13, 2018

9.1

Mister Miracle #10
August 1, 2018

9.4

Mister Miracle #11
September 19, 2018

9.1

8.6

Mister Miracle #12
November 14, 2018

9.0

7.9

Peacemaker Presents: The Vigilante / Eagly Double Feature! (2025)

5 issues show

8.0

7.1

Peacemaker Presents: The Vigilante / Eagly Double Feature! #1
March 26, 2025

8.8

8.5

Peacemaker Presents: The Vigilante / Eagly Double Feature! #2
April 23, 2025

9.0

8.2

Peacemaker Presents: The Vigilante / Eagly Double Feature! #3
May 28, 2025

9.0

N/A

Peacemaker Presents: The Vigilante / Eagly Double Feature! #4
June 25, 2025

N/A

Peacemaker Presents: The Vigilante / Eagly Double Feature! #5
August 27, 2025

7.4

Punisher (2014)

19 issues show

7.8

7.7

Punisher #1
February 5, 2014

7.4

7.3

Punisher #2
February 19, 2014

8.1

7.7

Punisher #3
March 5, 2014

7.8

Punisher #4
April 2, 2014

7.0

6.6

Punisher #5
May 7, 2014

7.8

7.2

Punisher #6
June 4, 2014

7.8

7.5

Punisher #7
June 18, 2014

6.8

7.0

Punisher #9
August 6, 2014

7.8

8.2

Punisher #10
September 3, 2014

7.9

8.0

Punisher #11
October 8, 2014

8.0

7.5

Punisher #12
November 19, 2014

6.5

5.7

Punisher #13
December 10, 2014

7.0

7.5

Punisher #14
January 7, 2015

8.0

7.5

Punisher #15
February 4, 2015

7.1

7.6

Punisher #16
March 18, 2015

7.9

7.8

Punisher #17
April 1, 2015

6.5

7.1

Punisher #18
May 6, 2015

6.7

7.4

Punisher #19
June 24, 2015

7.3

7.0

Punisher #20
July 22, 2015

8.4

8.2

Strange Adventures (2020)

11 issues show

8.8

8.3

Strange Adventures #1
March 4, 2020

8.5

7.9

Strange Adventures #2
June 17, 2020

8.4

Strange Adventures #3
July 15, 2020

8.5

8.6

Strange Adventures #4
August 5, 2020

8.2

8.0

Strange Adventures #5
September 2, 2020

8.9

8.5

Strange Adventures #6
October 14, 2020

8.4

7.9

Strange Adventures #7
December 2, 2020

9.0

7.9

Strange Adventures #8
January 27, 2021

7.8

7.7

Strange Adventures #9
March 31, 2021

7.8

8.4

Strange Adventures #10
May 26, 2021

8.3

8.6

Strange Adventures #11
July 28, 2021

8.0

7.8

The Activity

12 issues show

7.6

7.2

The Activity #1
December 21, 2011

8.0

6.5

The Activity #2
January 11, 2012

8.0

8.5

The Activity #4

8.0

8.5

The Activity #6
May 16, 2012

7.0

8.5

The Activity #7
July 18, 2012

8.5

The Activity #8
September 12, 2012

8.0

7.5

The Activity #9
October 17, 2012

8.0

7.5

The Activity #10
December 12, 2012

8.6

N/A

The Activity #11
January 30, 2013

7.8

N/A

The Activity #13
May 22, 2013

8.3

N/A

The Activity #15
October 2, 2013

7.0

7.5

The Activity #16
December 17, 2014

9.0

The Sheriff Of Babylon

12 issues show

9.1

The Sheriff Of Babylon #1
December 2, 2015

7.8

8.5

The Sheriff Of Babylon #2
January 6, 2016

9.4

8.9

The Sheriff Of Babylon #3
February 3, 2016

9.2

8.9

The Sheriff Of Babylon #4
March 2, 2016

9.5

9.4

The Sheriff Of Babylon #5
April 6, 2016

9.1

The Sheriff Of Babylon #6
May 4, 2016

8.9

8.8

The Sheriff Of Babylon #7
June 8, 2016

9.1

The Sheriff Of Babylon #8
July 6, 2016

9.7

9.4

The Sheriff Of Babylon #9
August 3, 2016

8.9

8.8

The Sheriff Of Babylon #10
September 7, 2016

8.0

8.9

The Sheriff Of Babylon #11
October 12, 2016

9.9

9.4

The Sheriff Of Babylon #12
November 2, 2016

9.0

7.0

Wonder Woman: Black & Gold: 2026 Special

9.0

7.0

Wonder Woman: Black & Gold: 2026 Special

All Comic Book Series

8.4

8.2

Batman (2016)

4 issues show

8.0

8.4

Batman #14
January 4, 2017

8.6

8.7

Batman #15
January 18, 2017

8.9

9.0

Batman #23
May 17, 2017

7.9

6.5

Batman #62
January 9, 2019

9.3

6.9

Batman / Catwoman: Special #1

9.2

7.6

Batman: Black & White #2

7.7

8.5

Batman: One Bad Day: The Riddler #1

7.9

7.6

Batman: The Brave and the Bold (2023)

5 issues show

8.3

7.7

Batman: The Brave and the Bold #1
May 17, 2023

8.2

7.1

Batman: The Brave and the Bold #2
June 28, 2023

6.8

6.9

Batman: The Brave and the Bold #4
August 23, 2023

8.3

8.1

Batman: The Brave and the Bold #5
September 27, 2023

8.0

Batman: The Brave and the Bold #9
January 24, 2024

6.2

5.1

Heroes In Crisis

2 issues show

6.7

5.5

Heroes In Crisis #6
February 27, 2019

5.7

4.7

Heroes In Crisis #8
April 24, 2019

7.3

5.1

Legion of Super-Heroes #9

9.2

9.1

Mister Miracle (2017)

12 issues show

9.2

9.1

Mister Miracle #1
August 9, 2017

9.2

9.0

Mister Miracle #2
September 13, 2017

8.8

9.0

Mister Miracle #3
October 11, 2017

9.1

9.4

Mister Miracle #4
November 8, 2017

9.3

9.4

Mister Miracle #5
December 13, 2017

9.1

9.0

Mister Miracle #6
January 10, 2018

9.3

9.0

Mister Miracle #7
March 14, 2018

9.1

8.9

Mister Miracle #8
April 18, 2018

9.2

9.1

Mister Miracle #9
June 13, 2018

9.1

Mister Miracle #10
August 1, 2018

9.4

Mister Miracle #11
September 19, 2018

9.1

8.6

Mister Miracle #12
November 14, 2018

9.0

7.9

Peacemaker Presents: The Vigilante / Eagly Double Feature! (2025)

5 issues show

8.0

7.1

Peacemaker Presents: The Vigilante / Eagly Double Feature! #1
March 26, 2025

8.8

8.5

Peacemaker Presents: The Vigilante / Eagly Double Feature! #2
April 23, 2025

9.0

8.2

Peacemaker Presents: The Vigilante / Eagly Double Feature! #3
May 28, 2025

9.0

N/A

Peacemaker Presents: The Vigilante / Eagly Double Feature! #4
June 25, 2025

N/A

Peacemaker Presents: The Vigilante / Eagly Double Feature! #5
August 27, 2025

7.4

Punisher (2014)

19 issues show

7.8

7.7

Punisher #1
February 5, 2014

7.4

7.3

Punisher #2
February 19, 2014

8.1

7.7

Punisher #3
March 5, 2014

7.8

Punisher #4
April 2, 2014

7.0

6.6

Punisher #5
May 7, 2014

7.8

7.2

Punisher #6
June 4, 2014

7.8

7.5

Punisher #7
June 18, 2014

6.8

7.0

Punisher #9
August 6, 2014

7.8

8.2

Punisher #10
September 3, 2014

7.9

8.0

Punisher #11
October 8, 2014

8.0

7.5

Punisher #12
November 19, 2014

6.5

5.7

Punisher #13
December 10, 2014

7.0

7.5

Punisher #14
January 7, 2015

8.0

7.5

Punisher #15
February 4, 2015

7.1

7.6

Punisher #16
March 18, 2015

7.9

7.8

Punisher #17
April 1, 2015

6.5

7.1

Punisher #18
May 6, 2015

6.7

7.4

Punisher #19
June 24, 2015

7.3

7.0

Punisher #20
July 22, 2015

8.4

8.2

Strange Adventures (2020)

11 issues show

8.8

8.3

Strange Adventures #1
March 4, 2020

8.5

7.9

Strange Adventures #2
June 17, 2020

8.4

Strange Adventures #3
July 15, 2020

8.5

8.6

Strange Adventures #4
August 5, 2020

8.2

8.0

Strange Adventures #5
September 2, 2020

8.9

8.5

Strange Adventures #6
October 14, 2020

8.4

7.9

Strange Adventures #7
December 2, 2020

9.0

7.9

Strange Adventures #8
January 27, 2021

7.8

7.7

Strange Adventures #9
March 31, 2021

7.8

8.4

Strange Adventures #10
May 26, 2021

8.3

8.6

Strange Adventures #11
July 28, 2021

8.0

7.8

The Activity

12 issues show

7.6

7.2

The Activity #1
December 21, 2011

8.0

6.5

The Activity #2
January 11, 2012

8.0

8.5

The Activity #4

8.0

8.5

The Activity #6
May 16, 2012

7.0

8.5

The Activity #7
July 18, 2012

8.5

The Activity #8
September 12, 2012

8.0

7.5

The Activity #9
October 17, 2012

8.0

7.5

The Activity #10
December 12, 2012

8.6

N/A

The Activity #11
January 30, 2013

7.8

N/A

The Activity #13
May 22, 2013

8.3

N/A

The Activity #15
October 2, 2013

7.0

7.5

The Activity #16
December 17, 2014

9.0

The Sheriff Of Babylon

12 issues show

9.1

The Sheriff Of Babylon #1
December 2, 2015

7.8

8.5

The Sheriff Of Babylon #2
January 6, 2016

9.4

8.9

The Sheriff Of Babylon #3
February 3, 2016

9.2

8.9

The Sheriff Of Babylon #4
March 2, 2016

9.5

9.4

The Sheriff Of Babylon #5
April 6, 2016

9.1

The Sheriff Of Babylon #6
May 4, 2016

8.9

8.8

The Sheriff Of Babylon #7
June 8, 2016

9.1

The Sheriff Of Babylon #8
July 6, 2016

9.7

9.4

The Sheriff Of Babylon #9
August 3, 2016

8.9

8.8

The Sheriff Of Babylon #10
September 7, 2016

8.0

8.9

The Sheriff Of Babylon #11
October 12, 2016

9.9

9.4

The Sheriff Of Babylon #12
November 2, 2016

9.0

7.0

Wonder Woman: Black & Gold: 2026 Special

2025 In Review:

Top Comic Series
Top Comic Issues
Top New Series

Reviews for the Week of...

February

11 4

January

28 21 14