Eda Thomas Bagwell Comic Reviews

9.4
Reviewer For: Nerd Initiative
Reviews: 41
View By: Series Series Rating Issue Rating Review Date

Aditya Bidikar and his art team continue to astound and amaze. So far, “In Your Skin” is something that feels truly timeless, especially in this modern age of fandom and social media. Bidikar continues daring to ask the questions everyone else is afraid to, and I love this all the more for it. I feel as if it’s safe to say we have a modern horror classic on our hands, and you should be reading.


View Issue Full Review

So far, this whole team can do no wrong. From Seeley & O’Nan’s intense story evoking the likes of “Hamlet” or “Death Note” to the insane artwork, “Pretty Hate Machine” is a whole different beast. This is a beast clawing its way from the pits of Hell itself, demanding to be read, and it should be.


View Issue Full Review

De Felici is truly a wonder maker. From his writing to his artwork, he excels on both fronts, something that isn’t easy to do. I’m super excited to see where things go from here!


View Issue Full Review

When the writer, artist and colorist all come together to create a triple threat, you know you have something amazing on your hands. From the humor-laced intensity in Sniegoski’s writing to the gothic realism of Menna & Augusto, “Vampirella: Armageddon #11” is a must add to your collection this week! With next month set for the finale, now’s as good a time as any to get caught up!


View Issue Full Review

I don’t think I can really praise this run enough. It’s so far remained consistently stellar and this installment doesn’t disappoint. I can easily say that you can read all three of these first issues and not at all feel like you’re missing a beat. The creative team is putting in the work and it shows!


View Issue Full Review

While the final pages may prove to be a bit divisive amongst fans, the team stuck the landing overall. With as hard a project as this run, Peach Momoko and crew kept things tied tight with an overall great story and utterly fantastic artwork. All involved in this genre-defining project should pat themselves on the back and stand proud of the perfection they created. “Sai: Dimensional Rivals” is an absolute masterclass from start to finish, and I’ll absolutely be buying the trade paperback when it releases.


View Issue Full Review

While things might feel a bit too fast paced for some, Hannah Rose May crafted yet another stellar entry to her “Smile” series. Tension and horror ran high, with stellar art and color work to boot! The creative team continues to prove they’re here to stay and that Rose May is an absolute icon on the rise. With only a few issues left, I’m more than excited to see where things go from here!


View Issue Full Review

From the tenseness, horror, and relatability of writing to the matching tenacity of the artwork, Priest led and created yet another highly exceptional installment of “Vampirella”. One will laugh as much as they feel fear and will want to keep coming back for another bite.


View Issue Full Review

From start to finish, Williams crafted a genuinely great start to a so far light-hearted horror ride! A true page turner that’s sure to please anyone missing the era of “E.T.” to “Iron Giant.” The writing is coupled only by the great art and colors from Vendrell and Sastre!


View Issue Full Review

From the message being told to the almost painting-like artwork, everything about SIKTC #47 is an absolute masterpiece. This deep into the franchise, Tynion and crew continue to prove that true artistry never runs out of gas and that it can always dig deeper. This series continues to be an absolute triumph!


View Issue Full Review

While expansions can be tricky, Brombal and team go above and beyond in nailing it. Gripping you tight and pulling you into the tension, this is an incredible slow burn with art & colors to match. For longtime fans of the SIKTC series, this is more than worth the read. A surely amazing ride lies ahead.


View Issue Full Review

The Rosenberg brothers weren’t on my radar prior, but after reading this, they certainly are now. They crafted something that’s exemplary of life and the human experience. In everything from the writing to the artwork, “If Destruction Be Our Lot” is a masterpiece. It’s arguably one of the best comics to come out this year and I’m undoubtedly having this be my pick of the week.


View Issue Full Review

This inaugural issue from writer Delilah S. Dawson is an absolute standout that I can’t wait to read more of. From the dark themes to the excellent character writing and artwork, “Sleepy Hollow: The Witches of the Western Wood” is series you need to have on your radar!


View Issue Full Review

I can’t imagine this having been an easy feat for David Avallone to take on as sole writer, but he did an absolutely stellar job! Paired with this insane team of artists and Omi Remalante Jr., they created something that was truly special from start to finish. Whether you enjoy none or all of these characters, I can’t recommend this book enough. If you get the chance to read it, do.


View Issue Full Review

From the first page to the last, this was a finale that really stuck the landing. Conner and Palmiotti crafted a story that’s hard to put down. Full of laughter, chaos, and crazy sci-fi, a good time will be had by all who pick up this run!


View Issue Full Review

De Felici does nothing but work wonders in this introductory issue. So far, this is like nothing I’ve ever read before, and it got me hook, line and sinker.


View Issue Full Review

Bunn, Aneke, and Martín continue to prove that they’re a force to be reckoned with. From the insane artwork to the deep storytelling, “Ripcord” continues to say that it deserves to exist and will do whatever it takes to get the recognition it deserves. This should be an immediate add to your pull list if it isn’t already.


View Issue Full Review

As sad as I am to see this series go, I’m beyond ecstatic that I got to experience it as it happened. From the first issue to the last, Gilly and crew take readers on a wild ride, not allowing us to let go. The writing, art and colors worked together to create something truly electric and worth remembering. I’d even go so far as to say that Gilly, Di Caprio and Angiolini cemented themselves in Tomb Raider’s legacy.


View Issue Full Review

While the writing from Kelly and Morris leaves a lot to be desired, the artwork from Pérez and Guru does a lot to carry here. Where the writing lost its heart, the artwork created excitement and makes the reader feel like they’re apart of the action. All things considered, I’m anxious to see where this is all going and I hope things make more sense down the line.Be sure to read more from me here as well as follow my socials!


View Issue Full Review

Tyler Boss and Martin Simmonds have come together to create an absolute masterclass in how to do horror. Boss created a beast, perfectly adapting a gothic classic for modern audiences. If you aren’t yet reading this, you need to be!


View Issue Full Review

From beginning to end, this was a read that was tough to put down. Priest shows just how he’s an expert at the craft and what magic can be created by trusting your artist. Whether you’re a longtime fan or a reader just wondering where to start, this book is perfection personified. An absolute bona fide standout in Priest’s illustrious career.


View Issue Full Review

If I didn’t say it before, I’ll say it now, “Smile: For The Camera” more than proves that Hannah Rose May needs to be considered as one of the greats in horror comics. Issue #2 keeps up the energy left from the start and doesn’t hold back. She’s taking chances, and the art & colors of Puglia and Kelly follow through. This run so far is an absolute must read for any horror enthusiast.


View Issue Full Review

If you love horrifying violence partnered with top notch writing and a deep message, Sniegoski’s “Vampirella: Armageddon” is for you. Impactful, heavy, tense and slightly sadistic. You’ll be yearning for more before you even finish.


View Issue Full Review

While the panel work draws this back a bit, the writing and overall artwork from Panosian and Spalletta make this an absolutely spellbinding read! Always turning on it’s cruel heels, “Alice: Forever After #3” will leave you both speechless and with plenty of questions with future answers.


View Issue Full Review

Seeley, O’Nan, Armitano and Stevens all worked together to create a beautiful and horrifying take on a Hamlet-like story that would surely make Shakespeare himself proud. If you love tense tales of revenge, murder, devious beings and a dash of teen-angst, this is the run for you!


View Issue Full Review

What can I say that I didn’t say already? The energy, the pacing, the artwork… everything is top notch. Peach Momoko and crew proved that they came to take the Marvel multiverse by force and that they refuse to be topped. This run is a comic lover’s dream and if you aren’t reading, you need to be.


View Issue Full Review

Gilly, Di Caprio, and Angiolini all come together to create one of Lara’s best adventures to date! Any fan not reading “Sacred Artifacts” is missing out on a truly exciting time.


View Issue Full Review

From the Boss levels of writing to the art that echoes one of the comic book greats, this is a run that’s more than worth a look at for any horror fiend. That goes double for anyone who’s a monster for the Universal Monsters.


View Issue Full Review

From Priest’s fantastic, important messaging and story to the gorgeous artwork of Ergün Gündüz, this is a stellar book from start to finish! It’s most certainly one that I can see myself re-reading multiple times over without hesitation.


View Issue Full Review

From Bunn’s no-holds-barred writing to the bone-chilling artistry of Aneke and Patricia Martin, “Ripcord” is something you need to keep on your radar. This, for sure, is something I’ll be adding to my pull list, guaranteed.


View Issue Full Review

Between the artwork of Rossi Gifford being a standout and the writing from both Kieron Gillen and Ryan North being horrifically stellar, “Super Creepshow” is sure to deliver the frights and screams to any and all who add it to their collection!


View Issue Full Review

From the masterclass writing that Sniegoski delivers to the horrifyingly great art and coloring of Menna and Augusto, this is a run everyone needs to keep an eye on! I couldn’t put this down and I don’t think you will either.


View Issue Full Review

From the slasher influence to the properly grungy art style, everything about “Chrome” is an absolute masterclass of both the genre and the property. I can’t recommend this enough and intend to have everyone I know read it.


View Issue Full Review

While the main plot takes a bit of a backseat, Palmiotti & Conner deliver a fun time with an interesting twist, coupled with fantastic artwork! This run overall is so far something special, and I very much look forward to the future!


View Issue Full Review

In everything from the message to the tone and the artwork, “Sonja Reborn #6” is an utterly stellar read from start to finish! Priest is arguably at his best here, and the art more than lives up to the writing. I, for one, can’t wait to see what more is being cooked up for the character come May 2026!


View Issue Full Review

It should come as a surprise to no one that Kirkman and crew killed it here, as they always do. If you love the Spider-Man or the “Invincible” series on Amazon, this is a must read!


View Issue Full Review

Gilly’s “Sacred Artifacts” remains a perfect gateway for newcomers while being a fantastic read for longtime fans! I can’t recommend this series enough.


View Issue Full Review

The writing is absolutely alluring with a staunch, powerful message and artwork that backs it up near perfectly. Any “Vampirella” fan will want to sink their teeth in!


View Issue Full Review

Yancy: Obviously, there’s a lot more to be revealed in this story. But so far Sai’s story is one of filled with wonders, intrigue and a fun mystery. This is an incredible collaboration by some of the most talented creators in comic books. Marvel is setting a new standard for teamwork in storytelling with Peach Momoko at the forefront of this project.


View Issue Full Review

From the writing of Hannah Rose May to the artwork of Miriana Puglia and Dearbhla Kelly, this is easily a piece that any horror fan will gain a smile from! Absolutely stellar from start to finish and I can’t wait for more.


View Issue Full Review

Everyone clearly brought their A-game here and closed this run out on the perfect finale. While I'm sad to see it go, I absolutely can't wait to see where the Riders go from here.


View Issue Full Review

Reviews for the Week of...

June

3

May

27 20 13 6

April

29