This was a really good follow-up story to Long Halloween. It follows a lot of the same narrative beats, but it's different enough in it's own right to warrant its existence. Loeb and Sale produce another gripping whodunnit story with a lot of powerful character moments, particularly for Batman, Catwoman, Alfred, Gordon, and Dick. Also, reading this after having watched The Penguin, it's clear this book was a huge inspiration for that show, which is cool since Long Halloween was one of the inspirations for The Batman. Overall this was a solid Batman tale and it's a nice continuation of the story for anyone who felt they needed more after Long Halloween.