2018 Top Trades - Indie

Top Series Top New Series Top Issues Most Reviewed Issues Top Trades

2025 2024 2023 2022 2021 2020 2019 2018 2017 2016 2015 2014 2013

To be eligible for our 'Top Trades of 2018' year end RoundUps, the trade must have been released in 2018 and had at least 20 critic issue reviews or 5 user reviews.

Overall DC Marvel Image Indie
Critic
User
1
Secret Weapons Collected

Secret Weapons Collected

Valiant Comics

8.9
57 Reviews
2
TMNT: Dimension X Vol. 1

TMNT: Dimension X Vol. 1

IDW Publishing

7.6
34 Reviews
3
Hellboy and the B.P.R.D.: 1954 Vol. 1

Hellboy and the B.P.R.D.: 1954 Vol. 1

Dark Horse Comics

7.8
28 Reviews
4
Satellite Falling Vol. 1

Satellite Falling Vol. 1

IDW Publishing

8.2
39 Reviews
5
Harbinger: Renegade Vol. 2: Massacre

Harbinger: Renegade Vol. 2: Massacre

Valiant Comics

7.9
45 Reviews
6
Mech Cadet Yu Vol. 1

Mech Cadet Yu Vol. 1

Boom! Studios

8.8
40 Reviews
7
Giant Days Vol. 2 Not On The Test Edition

Giant Days Vol. 2 Not On The Test Edition

Boom! Studios

7.9
32 Reviews
8
Warlord of Mars Vol. 2 Omnibus

Warlord of Mars Vol. 2 Omnibus

Dynamite Entertainment

7.9
35 Reviews
9
Savage Things : Collected

Savage Things : Collected

Vertigo

8.6
52 Reviews
10
Predator: Hunters : Collected

Predator: Hunters : Collected

Dark Horse Comics

7.7
30 Reviews
11
WWE Vol. 2

WWE Vol. 2

Boom! Studios

7.7
22 Reviews
12
X-O Manowar Vol. 3: Emporer

X-O Manowar Vol. 3: Emporer

Valiant Comics

8.7
27 Reviews
13
Briggs Land Vol. 2: Lone Wolves

Briggs Land Vol. 2: Lone Wolves

Dark Horse Comics

8.4
25 Reviews
15
Godshaper Collected

Godshaper Collected

Boom! Studios

9.2
44 Reviews
18
Clue Collected

Clue Collected

IDW Publishing

8.2
40 Reviews
20
Robotech Vol. 1

Robotech Vol. 1

Titan Books

7.4
32 Reviews

Reviews for the Week of...

January

21 14 7

December

31 24