Marvel Comics May 2004

Astonishing X-Men (2004)

7.1

Critic Reviews

248

7.0

User Reviews

583

Dream-team creators Joss Whedon (creator of TV's Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Firefly and fan-favorite film Serenity) and John Cassaday (Planetary, Captain America) bring you the explosive #1 issue of the all-new flagship X-Men series! As part of X-men: Reload, this issue marks a return to classic greatness and the beginning of a brand-new era for the X-Men.

Issue (68) Annuals (1) Trades (14) Pulled By (2)

ISSUES – 68

critic

user

Rating	Issue	Writer	Artist
8.0 1 Reviews N/A	68	Marjorie Liu	Gabriel Hernandez Walta
6.9 3 Reviews 8.0 1 Reviews	67	Marjorie Liu	Amilcar Pinna
7.6 2 Reviews N/A	66	Marjorie Liu	Phil Noto
7.0 1 Reviews N/A	65	Marjorie Liu	Gabriel Hernandez Walta
8.0 1 Reviews N/A	64	Marjorie Liu	Phil Noto
8.0 3 Reviews N/A	63	Marjorie Liu	Phil Noto
7.5 1 Reviews 9.5 1 Reviews	62	Marjorie Liu	Gabriel Hernandez Walta
7.2 3 Reviews N/A	61	Marjorie M. Liu	Matteo Buffagni
6.8 4 Reviews N/A	60	Marjorie Liu	Giuseppe Camuncoli
7.5 2 Reviews N/A	59	Marjorie Liu	Phil Noto
8.1 2 Reviews N/A	58	Marjorie Liu	Gabriel Hernandez Walta
N/A N/A	57	Marjorie Liu	Felix Ruiz
5.0 1 Reviews N/A	56	Marjorie Liu	Mike Perkins
6.6 1 Reviews N/A	55	Marjorie Liu	Mike Perkins
N/A N/A	54	Marjorie Liu	Mike Perkins
5.5 4 Reviews N/A	53	Marjorie Liu	Mike Perkins
8.2 3 Reviews N/A	52	Marjorie Liu	Mike Perkins
7.4 11 Reviews N/A	51	Marjorie Liu	Mike Perkins
6.8 13 Reviews N/A	50	Marjorie Liu	Mike Perkins
8.1 2 Reviews N/A	49	Marjorie Liu	Mike Perkins
7.2 4 Reviews N/A	48	Marjorie Liu	Mike Perkins
6.5 2 Reviews 8.5 1 Reviews	47	Greg Pak	Mike McKone
7.1 4 Reviews N/A	46	Greg Pak	Mike McKone
7.5 2 Reviews N/A	45	Greg Pak	Mike McKone
7.0 3 Reviews N/A	44	Greg Pak	Mike McKone
7.2 2 Reviews 7.5 2 Reviews	43	James Asmus	David Yardin
8.0 1 Reviews N/A	42	Christos Gage	Salvador Larroca
8.2 2 Reviews N/A	41	Daniel Way	Nick Bradshaw
N/A N/A	40	Christos N. Gage	Juan Bobillo
7.0 2 Reviews N/A	39	Daniel Way	Jason Pearson
5.2 3 Reviews N/A	38	Christos Gage	Juan Bobillo
5.6 4 Reviews N/A 1 Reviews	37	Daniel Way	Jason Pearson
6.0 1 Reviews N/A 1 Reviews	36	Daniel Way	Jason Pearson
8.0 1 Reviews 7.5 4 Reviews	35	Warren Ellis	Phil Jimenez
7.5 5 Reviews 7.8 4 Reviews	34	Warren Ellis	Phil Jimenez
6.5 2 Reviews 8.0 3 Reviews	33	Warren Ellis	Phil Jimenez
6.7 4 Reviews 7.3 3 Reviews	32	Warren Ellis	Phil Jimenez
6.6 5 Reviews 7.5 3 Reviews	31	Warren Ellis	Phil Jiminez
7.2 4 Reviews 6.8 5 Reviews	30	Warren Ellis	Simone Bianchi
6.6 6 Reviews 6.8 5 Reviews	29	Warren Ellis	Simone Bianchi
6.9 3 Reviews 6.7 4 Reviews	28	Warren Ellis	Simone Bianchi
6.1 4 Reviews 6.5 4 Reviews	27	Warren Ellis	Simone Bianchi
6.5 6 Reviews 6.8 5 Reviews	26	Warren Ellis	Simone Bianchi
7.5 10 Reviews 6.4 5 Reviews	25	Warren Ellis	Simone Bianchi
5.9 4 Reviews 8.1 19 Reviews	24	Joss Whedon	John Cassaday
8.9 7 Reviews 8.6 20 Reviews	23	Joss Whedon	John Cassaday
7.5 2 Reviews 8.0 20 Reviews	22	Joss Whedon	John Cassaday
7.1 4 Reviews 7.9 20 Reviews	21	Joss Whedon	John Cassaday
7.1 4 Reviews 8.1 20 Reviews	20	Joss Whedon	John Cassaday
7.5 6 Reviews 7.9 20 Reviews	19	Joss Whedon	John Cassady
7.4 5 Reviews 8.1 20 Reviews	18	Joss Whedon	John Cassaday
7.2 6 Reviews 8.4 20 Reviews	17	Joss Whedon	John Cassaday
7.5 4 Reviews 7.9 20 Reviews	16	Joss Whedon	John Cassaday
7.7 7 Reviews 8.0 20 Reviews	15	Joss Whedon	John Cassaday
8.3 3 Reviews 8.2 20 Reviews	14	Joss Whedon	John Cassaday
6.4 10 Reviews 7.8 20 Reviews	13	Joss Whedon	John Cassaday
4.0 3 Reviews 7.6 24 Reviews	12	Joss Whedon	John Cassaday
4.7 3 Reviews 7.7 24 Reviews	11	Joss Whedon	John Cassaday
5.3 3 Reviews 7.7 24 Reviews	10	Joss Whedon	John Cassaday
5.0 3 Reviews 7.7 25 Reviews	9	Joss Whedon	John Cassaday
7.0 4 Reviews 8.1 25 Reviews	8	Joss Whedon	John Cassaday
8.5 4 Reviews 8.4 25 Reviews	7	Joss Whedon	John Cassaday
8.3 7 Reviews 8.5 23 Reviews	6	Joss Whedon	John Cassaday
8.0 2 Reviews 8.4 23 Reviews	5	Joss Whedon	John Cassaday
8.2 4 Reviews 8.7 23 Reviews	4	Joss Whedon	John Cassaday
8.4 5 Reviews 8.8 24 Reviews	3	Joss Whedon	John Cassaday
8.0 3 Reviews 8.5 25 Reviews	2	Joss Whedon	John Cassaday
6.6 7 Reviews 8.6 27 Reviews	1	Joss Whedon	John Cassaday

Rating	Trade	Issues
6.8 48 Reviews 9.1 7 Reviews	Vol. 1 Ultimate Collection	12
7.4 62 Reviews 8.6 8 Reviews	Vol. 2 Ultimate Collection	13
7.9 28 Reviews 8.8 9 Reviews	Vol. 1: Gifted	6
5.8 20 Reviews 8.1 7 Reviews	Vol. 2: Dangerous	6
7.4 35 Reviews 8.8 5 Reviews	Vol. 3: Torn	6
7.3 27 Reviews 8.9 5 Reviews	Vol. 4: Unstoppable	6
6.6 39 Reviews N/A	Vol. 5: Ghost Box	8
7.1 17 Reviews 7.0 1 Reviews	Vol. 6: Exogenetic	5
6.7 9 Reviews 7.0 1 Reviews	Vol. 7: Monstrous	4
6.8 6 Reviews 7.0 1 Reviews	Vol. 8: Children of the Brood	4
7.0 11 Reviews 7.0 1 Reviews	Vol. 9: Exalted	4
7.4 30 Reviews 7.5 1 Reviews	Vol. 10: Northstar	4
6.4 12 Reviews 6.5 1 Reviews	Vol. 11: Weaponized	5
7.6 16 Reviews 8.0 1 Reviews	Vol. 12: Unmasked	9

Astonishing X-Men (2004)

Critic Reviews

User Reviews

ISSUES – 68

Annuals - 1

TRADES - 14

Pulled By - 2 Users

2025 In Review:

Reviews for the Week of...

January

December