Supernatural #1

Writer Greg Pak does an excellent job of capturing the vibe and feel of the earlier Supernatural episodes, with Dean still teasing Sam about his college education and Sam still grappling with the trauma of his girlfriend's murder at the hands of Azazel. I also appreciated that the CEO of the company they were investigating turned out to be a more complex villain than the actual monster Sam and Dean were hunting, adding an extra layer of tension and intrigue to the story. Read Full Review

Supernatural #1 delivers a solid, scary standalone story that builds on the world of the hit television series. Read Full Review

Supernatural #1 did a good job of introducing the comic book reader to this world, as well as season 1 Sam and Dean. For people already part of the "Supernatural Family they'll enjoy all the callbacks. While, those new to this world get a quick introduction to some very important characteristics and tools of the Winchester brothers. Read Full Review

A promising return that captures the spirit of early Supernatural. Pak and Messias understand what made the show work in its prime, delivering a case-of-the-week that feels authentic even if it's compressed into 25 pages. Read Full Review

Supernatural #1 is a fun debut with a certain charm about it. While it doesn't get me to want to go back and watch the television series it does make me want to continue to read the comics. It also makes it clear why it has such a solid fandom. The comic is fun and entertaining, perfect comic reading to distract and just lay back and enjoy. Read Full Review

Messias crafts some great art throughout the issue. I like the visual style of the issue and the character designs. Read Full Review

SUPERNATURAL #1 is a fiery, fast-talking first issue that nails the TV show's spirit, even as it occasionally fumbles the landing. It's a fun, breezy ride that's light on horror but heavy on Winchester charm and whiskey-bottle stakes. When the next monster shows up, count on the brothers and their questionable credit to keep things loud and messy. Read Full Review

fzanca

Nov 11, 2025

I think Pak was able to get the voices right, but I was disappointed that he went back all the way to the beginning of the TV series. The story was decent enough. I think it's a mini-series, so I'll continue it. My Comic Review Channel - https://youtu.be/HiZds_UkaVw