Astonishing X-Men (2004)

Astonishing X-Men (2004)

Publisher: Marvel Comics Release: May 2004 - Oct 2013 Issues: 68   Annuals: 1 Collected Volumes: 14 Critic Reviews: 248  User Reviews: 577
7.1 Avg. Critic Rating
7.9 Avg. User Rating

Dream-team creators Joss Whedon (creator of TV's Buffy the Vampire Slayer, Firefly and fan-favorite film Serenity) and John Cassaday (Planetary, Captain America) bring you the explosive #1 issue of the all-new flagship X-Men series! As part of X-men: Reload, this issue marks a return to classic greatness and the beginning of a brand-new era for the X-Men.

User Ratings Critic Ratings
Rating Issue Writer Artist Reviews
8.0
N/A
 #68 Marjorie Liu Gabriel Hernandez Walta
1
0
6.9
8.0
 #67 Marjorie Liu Amilcar Pinna
3
1
7.6
N/A
 #66 Marjorie Liu Phil Noto
2
0
7.0
N/A
 #65 Marjorie Liu Gabriel Hernandez Walta
1
0
8.0
N/A
 #64 Marjorie Liu Phil Noto
1
0
8.0
N/A
 #63 Marjorie Liu Phil Noto
3
0
7.5
9.5
 #62 Marjorie Liu Gabriel Hernandez Walta
1
1
7.2
N/A
 #61 Marjorie M. Liu Matteo Buffagni
3
0
6.8
N/A
 #60 Marjorie Liu Giuseppe Camuncoli
4
0
7.5
N/A
 #59 Marjorie Liu Phil Noto
2
0
8.1
N/A
 #58 Marjorie Liu Gabriel Hernandez Walta
2
0
N/A
N/A
 #57 Marjorie Liu Felix Ruiz
0
0
5.0
N/A
 #56 Marjorie Liu Mike Perkins
1
0
6.6
N/A
 #55 Marjorie Liu Mike Perkins
1
0
N/A
N/A
 #54 Marjorie Liu Mike Perkins
0
0
5.5
N/A
 #53 Marjorie Liu Mike Perkins
4
0
8.2
N/A
 #52 Marjorie Liu Mike Perkins
3
0
7.4
N/A
 #51 Marjorie Liu Mike Perkins
11
0
6.8
N/A
 #50 Marjorie Liu Mike Perkins
13
0
8.1
N/A
 #49 Marjorie Liu Mike Perkins
2
0
7.2
N/A
 #48 Marjorie Liu Mike Perkins
4
0
6.5
8.5
 #47 Greg Pak Mike McKone
2
1
7.1
N/A
 #46 Greg Pak Mike McKone
4
0
7.5
N/A
 #45 Greg Pak Mike McKone
2
0
7.0
N/A
 #44 Greg Pak Mike McKone
3
0
7.2
7.5
 #43 James Asmus David Yardin
2
2
8.0
N/A
 #42 Christos Gage Salvador Larroca
1
0
8.2
N/A
 #41 Daniel Way Nick Bradshaw
2
0
N/A
N/A
 #40 Christos N. Gage Juan Bobillo
0
0
7.0
N/A
 #39 Daniel Way Jason Pearson
2
0
5.2
N/A
 #38 Christos Gage Juan Bobillo
3
0
5.6
N/A
 #37 Daniel Way Jason Pearson
4
1
6.0
N/A
 #36 Daniel Way Jason Pearson
1
1
8.0
7.5
 #35 Warren Ellis Phil Jimenez
1
4
7.5
7.8
 #34 Warren Ellis Phil Jimenez
5
4
6.5
8.0
 #33 Warren Ellis Phil Jimenez
2
3
6.7
7.3
 #32 Warren Ellis Phil Jimenez
4
3
6.6
7.5
 #31 Warren Ellis Phil Jiminez
5
3
7.2
6.8
 #30 Warren Ellis Simone Bianchi
4
4
6.6
6.8
 #29 Warren Ellis Simone Bianchi
6
4
6.9
6.8
 #28 Warren Ellis Simone Bianchi
3
3
6.1
6.8
 #27 Warren Ellis Simone Bianchi
4
3
6.5
6.8
 #26 Warren Ellis Simone Bianchi
6
4
7.5
6.7
 #25 Warren Ellis Simone Bianchi
10
4
5.9
8.1
 #24 Joss Whedon John Cassaday
4
19
8.9
8.6
 #23 Joss Whedon John Cassaday
7
20
7.5
8.0
 #22 Joss Whedon John Cassaday
2
20
7.1
7.9
 #21 Joss Whedon John Cassaday
4
20
7.1
8.1
 #20 Joss Whedon John Cassaday
4
20
7.5
7.9
 #19 Joss Whedon John Cassady
6
20
7.4
8.1
 #18 Joss Whedon John Cassaday
5
20
7.2
8.4
 #17 Joss Whedon John Cassaday
6
20
7.5
7.9
 #16 Joss Whedon John Cassaday
4
20
7.7
8.0
 #15 Joss Whedon John Cassaday
7
20
8.3
8.2
 #14 Joss Whedon John Cassaday
3
20
6.4
7.8
 #13 Joss Whedon John Cassaday
10
20
4.0
7.6
 #12 Joss Whedon John Cassaday
3
24
4.7
7.7
 #11 Joss Whedon John Cassaday
3
24
5.3
7.7
 #10 Joss Whedon John Cassaday
3
24
5.0
7.7
 #9 Joss Whedon John Cassaday
3
25
7.0
8.1
 #8 Joss Whedon John Cassaday
4
25
8.5
8.4
 #7 Joss Whedon John Cassaday
4
25
8.3
8.5
 #6 Joss Whedon John Cassaday
7
23
8.0
8.4
 #5 Joss Whedon John Cassaday
2
23
8.2
8.7
 #4 Joss Whedon John Cassaday
4
23
8.4
8.8
 #3 Joss Whedon John Cassaday
5
24
8.0
8.5
 #2 Joss Whedon John Cassaday
3
25
6.6
8.6
 #1 Joss Whedon John Cassaday
7
27
Rating Annual Writer Artist Reviews
6.5
N/A
 #1 Christos Gage David Baldeon
3
0
  • mac75 Added: Apr 21, 2013
  • Dean Added: May 22, 2013

Reviews for the Week of...

November

5th

October

29th 22nd 15th 8th
More
© 2025