Detective Comics Vol. 5: Gothtopia

USER REVIEWS – 3

• 6.5
  

  Leto.rai

  Jun 11, 2018

  This volume is divided in 3 parts. On the first ine we have the Zero Year tie-in, followed up by the ending of the Man Bat storyline from some previous issues. This two issues are so out of place in this TPB. If the tie in is collected in a Zero Year collection, why puting it here too? Then the Man Bat issue should be alongside the other side story issues in another TPB, so it is a whole volume to develop that story. Then, is the Gothtopia storyline, the one of the title. It is an interesting one. It's not great, but good enough. I still feel some plot holes though, and it was a little quick and short, with an easy resolution. Then it is the 75th year anniversary issue, with a bunch of different stories from different authors. It's not b ad, but it still feels so out of place and context. So, yeah, Gothtopia is only on the title of this TPB. It could have been a grat TPB, if the story was larger and with a more consistent collection. more

  + Like • Comment
• 7.5
  

  jandals042

  Aug 06, 2021
  + Like • Comment
• 7.5
  

  OGuZHaN

  Oct 22, 2024
  + Like • Comment