CRITIC REVIEWS
Back to Top-
10
DC Comics News - Matthew Lloyd
Sep 12, 2018These reprints are worth the price of admission, but King and Kubert commence a Superman story that appears to be a classic in the making. Go out and be one of those who can say they were there for it! You won't be disappointed. Read Full Review
-
9.2
Black Nerd Problems - Mikkel Snyder
Sep 12, 2018King and Kubert set up a classical Superman story in mere pages that has convinced me to go out to a Walmart, buy one copy for myself and several copies for anyone who has ever asked me "where do I start?". This is a good place to start. And the best part is, it's not even everything in the Giant. Jeff Lemire, Geoff Johns, and Jeph Loeb, also write stories for the Giant, with Ed McGuinness, Joe Bennett, and Carlos Pacheco handling the art. Read Full Review
-
8.0
ComicBook.com - Russ Burlingame
Sep 12, 2018 -
8.0
Geekery Magazine - Chino DT
Sep 13, 2018The kidnapped girl gives a moral dilemma to Superman, he knows that Metropolis and the entire world itself is in constant danger and he can't abandon his duty neither can't leave a girl alone in some corner of the galaxy waiting to be rescued, later Bats communicate to Superman a bad announcement that will reach the heart of the Kryptonian and makes him take a hard decision. Read Full Review
-
6.5
Weird Science - Jim Werner
Oct 13, 2018Tom King steps up to the plate to show he can write Superman and while he succeeds to a degree, I wish the story could have been a bit brighter. Readers are treated to the typical King death and tragedy, but also some awesome art by Andy Kubert that plays like a greatest Superman battles mixtape. I wish we got more of the latter, but sadly that's not the case. We are left with a decent first issue that may have already lost site about why it exists in the first place. Read Full Review
2025 In Review:
