Captain Stone #1

CRITIC REVIEWS Back to Top

• 9.0

  ComicWow!TV - AD Boorman

  Dec 16, 2014

  McCormack and Sharp have written a tantalizing mystery.  In Charlie, they created an interesting character and created a need for her to discover what happened to the missing title character.  With this impressive  first, the creative team has promised a lot.  Hopefully they can deliver. Read Full Review

• 9.0

  Hulking Reviewer - Kareem Ali

  Dec 22, 2014

  Cap Stone #1 is a very engrossing issue about Charlie Chance's life story and how she became the Pet. It's an engaging story that details her thinking and her relationship with her father, the master thief Craven Panther. And the gorgeous artwork makes all of it that much more enjoyable. While reading it the first time I wasn't sure how this was connected to Captain Stone nor did I have any idea how he was a superhero. However it ultimately did connect to him in a manner that would make the search for him in the next issue(s) that much more intense. So I'm glad I decided to read this issue because now I want to see where the story is headed and don't want to miss anything. Read Full Review

• 9.0

  Chuck's Comic Of The Day - Chuck

  Dec 23, 2014

  There aren't too many comics around that offer a truly unique vision. Here's one now! Read Full Review

• 8.5

  AIPT - John F. Trent

  Dec 17, 2014

  Despite feeling betrayed by the advertising of the book, the story and character development of Charlie Chance is top notch. Her character is very relatable, but there is also a big mystery surrounding her. Liam Sharp's artwork is really the highlight of the book providing a psychedelic setting as well as different styles throughout the book. The cliffhanger does not really work due to a complete lack of information on Captain Stone.ProsLiam Sharp's psychedelic artworkExcellent character development of Charlie ChanceConsA sense of false marketing in regards to learning about the missing superhero, Captain StoneA cliffhanger that lacks any punch due to a lack of information on Captain StoneOverall Score: 8.5 Read Full Review

• 8.0

  Rhymes With Geek - J. Reifler

  Dec 16, 2014

  If you pick up Cap Stone #1 prepare to be challenged and don't expect any answers in this first issue. It's a seriesfor the discerning reader who likes painterly artwork anddreamy prose more than linear storytelling. Read Full Review

• 7.0

  TheCultDen - Reece Morris-Jones

  Dec 16, 2014

  This is somewhat eased by the qualityof writing and the artwork so I'm willing to give it a pass. Butunless next issue perks up and gets a move on, I'm consigning this tothe 'wait till it's out as a trade' category. Read Full Review

• 6.0

  Nerdly - Nicky Johnson

  Dec 17, 2014

  So Im a little stumped how to rate Cap Stone #1. As a simple reader, its pretty average. Im interested in seeing where the story goes and how the characters develop, but the art turns me off a little and just didnt make me want to finish. But I already have dissenting opinion from a trusted source from an artists point of view, and I do appreciate the writing style, so I think the only fair way to rate this is straight down the middle, but Ill be reading next issue for sure. Read Full Review

• 2.0

  Comic Bastards - Austin Lanari

  Dec 17, 2014

  Maybe there's hope for efficient and interesting motion comics to the point where some might make a good transition to the printed page. But Captain Stone #1 is the negative paragon of everything such transcriptions will have to fix in order to make this work in the future. Read Full Review